CONTACT US   SUBSCRIBE   PREMIUM   ADVERTISING

75F Hi 81F
Lo 68F

Recent Blog Posts

Jewish Group Urges Firing Of CNN's Dobbs Over Nazi Remarks

By JOSH GERSTEIN, Staff Reporter of the Sun | May 1, 2007

A Jewish group is calling for the firing of an outspoken CNN anchor, Lou Dobbs, after he accused advocates for illegal immigrants of using propaganda techniques employed by Nazi Germany.

"Comparisons to Nazis — especially in this day and age — are abhorrent," the president and CEO of the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, Gideon Aronoff, said in a statement yesterday. "Mr. Dobbs has crossed the line between responsible television commentary and hate-speech propaganda of his own. Keeping him on the air is essentially sanctioning by CNN — which is why we're asking CNN to remove Dobbs from his very public platform."

In a broadcast last week, Mr. Dobbs denounced immigrant-rights groups for portraying a crackdown on illegal immigration as a threat to foreigners who live in America legally.

"They might as well work for Herman Göring," Mr. Dobbs said. "I mean, they're running so much propaganda, trying to confuse the debate, the national dialogue, by talking about immigrants rather than illegal aliens and legal immigrants. It's mindless beyond belief."

A spokeswoman for CNN, Christa Robinson, did not respond directly to the call for Mr. Dobbs's ouster. However, she said his rhetoric was directed at those promoting sanctuary for illegal immigrants, such as Mayor Gavin Newsom of San Francisco.

"Lou Dobbs's expression of outrage was not directed toward anyone except the officials of San Francisco. Any offense taken by any other group was certainly not intended," Ms. Robinson said in a statement last night.

Mr. Dobbs's use of the Nazi metaphor was first reported on The New York Sun's political Web log, nysunpolitics.com.


Reader comments on this article

Read all comments

Comment By Date

Have all political commemtators gone OFF their minds?? First the "funny man" Imus lately of of MSNBC goes off.. now... [MORE]

Leonard Peracchio 

May 1, 2007 10:44

We Need More Like Dobb's in elected office. Than, maybe this government could get something done about securing our borders... [MORE]

Pedro 

May 2, 2007 19:01

Thank God for people like Lou Dobbs and Mayor Barletta of Hazleton, PA. They are decent Americans who care about... [MORE]

Irene 

May 2, 2007 21:27

lou dobbs seems to be the only personality on television that speaks for the average person like myself that doesn't... [MORE]

larry ross 

May 3, 2007 00:40

Pedro, if you believe that Lou Dobbs in what is needed as an elected official... look up this Millionaire's home... [MORE]

Leonard Peracchio 

May 3, 2007 12:49

Lou Dobbs enlightens middle class United States citizens who otherwise would depend on the liberal (oops! They now prefer to... [MORE]

Patricia 

Sep 18, 2007 14:51

The key difference between immigrants and illegal immigrants lies in the word illegal. Knowingly, these illegal immigrants break the law.... [MORE]

JT 

May 1, 2007 11:23

"Many refuse to learn the language. Our phone systems are clogged up with for spanish pick another number. What about... [MORE]

TexMex 

May 1, 2007 16:54

TexMex claims that Hispanics have lived in the U.S. before the coming of the Anglos-- SO WHAT?

What does that have... [MORE]

Native American 

May 2, 2007 17:01

I'm Jewish, some of my family perished in Nazi Germany, but this outcry over this whole deal is absolutely ridiculous.

Dobbs... [MORE]

Amy Wolff Sorter 

May 1, 2007 17:02

I wonder if this group is aware of the anti-Jewish rhetoric found in websites of the radical open-border organizations? They... [MORE]

Barbara 

May 1, 2007 18:23

I'm Jewish and an Imigrant. It took my father 7 years to enter the USA and He needed a "Sponser"... [MORE]

JD Berman 

May 2, 2007 08:51

First of all, Dobb's reference to Goering is wrong. He was not in charge of propaganda, he was the commander... [MORE]

JB 

May 2, 2007 10:24

In response to JB -- re: your rquest for specific websites showing anti-Jewish rhetoric. Some years ago, while researching for... [MORE]

Barbara 

May 2, 2007 16:10

Hi, just read some comments, when I saw this, written by JB-

NOTE TO BARBARA: Give us examples of those anti-semitic... [MORE]

Rocco 

May 2, 2007 21:51

Shouldn't Lou Dobbs have been referring to Goebbels, the Propaganda Minister? Goering did his share of broadcasting and interviews but... [MORE]

Mark Regan 

May 2, 2007 15:03

Just how insane can people get?

Lou Dobb's is almost the only one telling the truth about illegal aliens.

I say"Lou Dobb's... [MORE]

Carl clark 

May 2, 2007 15:36

A bunch of meshuginas. Lou Dobbs is the only sane voice on the networks. All the others are a buch... [MORE]

Wanda 

May 2, 2007 15:38

He made an analogy. So what? The people whining for his dismissal had an ax to grind to begin with.... [MORE]

truecitizen 

May 2, 2007 15:40

Yeah, sure, by all means. Let's fire the one commentator in the United States that people can actually get truthfull... [MORE]

Bobby 

May 2, 2007 15:54

Mr. Dobbs is the only member of the main stream media who speaks the truth and provides the real facts... [MORE]

Bren 

May 2, 2007 17:29

There should be a "Lou Dobbs on every station in the country. Notice how I say "country" fire all your... [MORE]

Renee 

Dec 21, 2007 19:28

That's the spirit, if you disagree with someone's political views, find some pretext to silence them.

[MORE]

lbs 

May 2, 2007 18:35

Truth is the absolute proff in a court of law.

Are, or aren't the tactics used by illegal immigration activists similar... [MORE]

Raymond Acuna 

May 2, 2007 19:05

If the pro illegal alien advocates think that they can pull an "Imus" on Lou Dobbs they'ed better think twice.... [MORE]

keanolo Smith 

May 2, 2007 19:48

Comment on this article

    Before submitting your comment, please provide a valid email address to complete the verification process.

    Fall Education
    A New York Sun Advertorial Section

    NEW YORK ›

    A Surge of Support for the Sun Voiced by Leaders in the City

    19 Columbia Freshmen Jump to the Ivy League From the Armed Forces

    2 Arrested for Running Prostitution Ring

    Community Organizers 'Appalled' by Their Portrayal

    City Teacher Charged With Section 8 Fraud

    More School Construction Is Urged for Manhattan

    NATIONAL ›

    Detroit Mayor To Step Down: 'I Lied Under Oath'

    Hurricane Ike Strengthens to Category 4

    Palin Speech Draws More Than 40 Million Viewers

    Abortion Rights Group Sees 'Discrepancy' in Palin Stance

    Bush To Announce Troop Levels in Iraq Next Week

    Abramoff Sentenced to Four Years in Corruption Scandal

    ARTS+ ›

    This Old House: Godfrey Cheshire's Family History

    Alan Ball Is Looking for Trouble

    Latinbeart 2008: The Heart of Latin America Is Strong

    'Mister Foe': The Boy Who Cried Mother

    'Everybody Wants To Be Italian': Love Is Never Saying ... Anything

    'August Evening': A Repressed Family in the Land of the Free