Recent Blog Posts

Reader comment on:
Online Tutors Based in India Claimed To Be From Texas

Submitted by Kamal Wadhera, Nov 7, 2006 03:41

We can see this issue in a very logical way keeping the
repercussions in mind.

First of all, Why NCLB : Among other reasons, below average teaching skills,
poor dedication of most teachers, largely a lack of accountability in the school education system
seem to be obvious.

I'm sure there must be statistical evidences for all these factors before a big
fund was allocated under NCLB.

Now that we've identified the symptom, we've to find a long term solution .
The objective is to help this school going generation reach above certain academic performance
levels so that their future is not left to fate.

Among many choices we've:

1. Give them the best academic inputs no matter where they'd come from

( India, China, Costa Rica or any other country on this earth because the issue is
so critical to the success of these hundreds of thousands of children. )

To the good luck of these children, this solution has become so very easy
because of internet and availability of better teachers)

2. Give them the teachers from the same country because some law doesn't permit something xyz ( social security no.etc.)

Are we not ignoring the fact that most of the teachers need not be blamed as
they are also products of the same school education system. Hence, the solution is outside the square.

Now, either we keep the law inflexible and let the future generations go down the drain
or
keep their future lives in mind as a firm objective and bring in a small change in the law, if necessary.


Above all, Imagine a scenario when these kids grow up with below average academic performance,
don't see anything worthwhile for themselves in the society, look back and realise that there was an opportunity
for them to be taught by better trainers from other countries but their political environment came in their way. Whether they'd forgive the system and what would this frustration lead to?


I leave the rest to the guesses of readers.


Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.

Other reader comments on this article

Comment By Date

Hi,Do you think that Indians are cheating Americans? Y do you want to stop the outsourcing from India? Your major... [MORE]

Anisha Paul 

Nov 9, 2006 00:52

Tutors are not americans or indians. they are guides, torch bearers for younger generation . if this role is being... [MORE]

malvinder ahuja 

Mar 21, 2008 07:55

It was indeed very shocking news that NYC laws don't permit tutoring from India. In fact it means NYC wants... [MORE]

Rajesh 

Nov 8, 2006 05:11

We can see this issue in a very logical way keeping the repercussions in mind. First of all, Why NCLB :...

Kamal Wadhera 

Nov 7, 2006 03:41

First, let us ask a question ourselves that if a member of your family is unable to get food in... [MORE]

Surjith.N 

Nov 7, 2006 20:32

If the district truly cared about these requirements and worked hard to enforce them with all providers, that would be... [MORE]

Vick 

Nov 3, 2006 15:47

I am sure that the dept of edu would have checked all these criterias before. They might have taken this... [MORE]

Shiva Kumar 

Nov 2, 2006 12:31

It is surprising to know that the NYC and the Education Board allowed the Socratic Learning Inc. without even checking... [MORE]

Vijay shankar 

Oct 30, 2006 12:04

No scandal can happen online.As long as the kids get proper tutorial guidance it does not mattee whether the tutor... [MORE]

glenn 

Nov 1, 2006 00:18

What made the NYC education department to introspect about the tutors after a long time? As of now, they would... [MORE]

Saravanan 

Nov 1, 2006 12:27

I hope they revive the project. Not the ban. [MORE]

Saravanan 

Nov 1, 2006 16:20

Comment on Online Tutors Based in India Claimed To Be From Texas

    Before submitting your comment, please provide a valid email address to complete the verification process.