Recent Editorials

Reader comment on:
Jim Webb's War
in response to reader comment: Another Northerner Misses the Point

Submitted by G. Ashleigh, Nov 14, 2006 20:32

they must have missed the honest version of that American history. Like the story that Pearl Harbor was "unprovoked." Just an example.

Just because your read something in a book or read it here, does not "make it so." Do some research on your own, and if your really interested, ask for the source of the information. There is more than one version of the story. Proof privides good insight should there be a bigoted or biased views. The following is a start. The 37th Texas link in the 2d link below provides a whole bunch of interesting related information.

As most educated folks would agree, "Slavery was a tertiary cause of secession and of the war. But, there are more causes and contradictions. Share these: http://www.petersburgexpress.com/Causes.html

One of my Black friend's heroes here in Virginia is Nathan Bedford Forest. Why! -- some would ask? The answer is my Black friend is well read in American history and knows who in history to trust. Also, the Fort Pillow propaganda was just that!

What were these Confederates doing?: http://www.petersburgexpress.com/Petersburg_Black-CSA.html

"The Confederate soldiers were our kinfolk and our heroes. We testify to the country our enduring fidelity to their memory. We commemorate their valor and devotion. There were some things that were not surrendered at Appomatox. We did not surrender our rights in history, nor was it one of the conditions of surrender that unfriendly lips should be suffered to tell the story of that war or that unfriendly hands should write the epitaphs of our Confederate dead. We have a right to teach our children the true history of that war, the causes that led up to it, and the principles involved."

Senator Edward W. Carmack, 1903

If you find anything in error, I'll correct it also

Sincerely,

A Virginian, &

Member of the Lundie family of Scotland.


Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.

Other reader comments on this article

Comment By Date

Seth Gitell wrote: "In his breathless praise of Forrest, Mr. Webb is paying tribute to the Confederate general in charge... [MORE]

Michael Kelley

Nov 16, 2006 07:59

For the writer, and "Fred", and all of those who wish to end this perpetual war of words about the... [MORE]

Val Green

Nov 15, 2006 19:57

Reference to your Webb article and his Confederate leanings-- had George Allen not denounced the Confederate flag, joined the NAACP... [MORE]

Brag Bowling

Nov 14, 2006 22:17

Mr. Gitell apparently belongs to the odd Northern school of thought which says that one can never talk about Nathan... [MORE]

Carla Ward

Nov 14, 2006 09:34

Mr. Gitell employs the classic Clinton maneuver of parse, attack, and obfuscate. Like many of the Webb critics during the... [MORE]

R Buckley

Nov 14, 2006 14:17

Ms. Ward apparently belongs to that odd school of thought that when someone like Forrest's name comes up, one should... [MORE]

Fred

Nov 14, 2006 14:30

The author should indeed have noted that Webb was talking about culture, customs, tradition, upbringing--and not genetics. Regarding Southern culture,... [MORE]

Richard L.A. Schaefer

Nov 14, 2006 14:58

Fred suggests that I am defensive for objecting to Mr. Gitell's insinuation that Mr. Webb owed it to the readers... [MORE]

Carla Ward

Nov 14, 2006 16:13

they must have missed the honest version of that American history. Like the story that Pearl Harbor was "unprovoked." Just...

G. Ashleigh

Nov 14, 2006 20:32

I guess defensiveness is all relative? Mr. Gitell does not insinuate much in his article, if I am reading the same... [MORE]

Fred

Nov 15, 2006 12:32

Mr Gitell wrote "...He has words of praise for the founder of the Ku Klux Klan..." Mr Gitell, Sir, I... [MORE]

Billy Bearden

Nov 14, 2006 07:44

Comment on Jim Webb's War

Name
Email Address
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. The New York Sun reserves the right to reject anything found to be objectionable.

Would You Like to Become a Sustaining Subscriber of the Sun? Sign up now

* Inquire about the Sun Seminars

Sustaining Subscriber Login

Follow The New York Sun

Facebook    Twitter    RSS    Join Mailing List

Buy China Wholesale Products on DHgate.com

For Vegas Show tickets, shop ShowTickets.com

Made-in-China.com

Planning an Orlando Vacation? Visit Best of Orlando!