re: Ask a Mormon - Reader comments at The New York Sun

Recent Blog Posts

Reader comment on:
How Tolerant Are We?
in response to reader comment: Ask a Mormon

Submitted by Aric, Apr 8, 2007 18:28

Having an axe to grind is not a phenomenon unique to former Mormons. I imagine every group that could be considered controversial faces strong criticism from former group members. This includes political parties, supporters of particular academic philosophies, religious groups, even the atheist movement. Just as you would not accept John Walker Lindh as the ultimate authority on America, it would be wrong to view disillusioned former members of any of any group a priori as the ultimate authority on the group with which they no longer affiliate. A more reasonable approach would be to hear out the criticisms, see how the group in question responds, make one's own observations to weigh the validity of the points raised by both sides, and then come to an informed conclusion, which will probably lie somewhere in between the views expressed by either side.

Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.

Other reader comments on this article

Comment	By	Date
So at a Harvard student forum questions were asked? This is supposed to mean that bigotry is going to keep... [MORE]	Mark	Apr 10, 2007 14:40
The Mormon Church (properly known as "The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints" - "LDS") presents a huge problem... [MORE]	Charles Snedecor	Apr 7, 2007 00:59
"There is a looseness to it and almost a disrespect of it that if it were applied to Catholicism or... [MORE]	Jonathan Kimball	Apr 6, 2007 11:46
Having an axe to grind is not a phenomenon unique to former Mormons. I imagine every group that could be...	Aric	Apr 8, 2007 18:28
It may be that the method of attack on Romney's faith is business as usual for politics. But most of... [MORE]	Lizzie Nelson	Mar 15, 2007 12:49
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Days Saints first ordained Blacks to the priesthood in 1832, which means Blacks were... [MORE]	Mark Hannig	Mar 15, 2007 11:31
I am a faithful and practicing Mormon, and feel that both the doctrine and history of my church is one... [MORE]	Thad Barkdull	Mar 27, 2007 21:33
As a political scientist, public administrator, and former elected municipal official, it seems to me that all those who want... [MORE]	E. Odell Miner, Ph.D.	Mar 14, 2007 18:33
The previous comments are all intelligent and helpful as is the article, but they all miss the point--the people publicizing... [MORE]	Joshua Steimle	Mar 14, 2007 00:04
It's interesting that much of the intolerance toward Mormonism that I've thus far read about are intolerance to their past... [MORE]	Sam	Mar 13, 2007 19:54
Actually Joseph Smith Jr. also ran for President (just to get that record straight). This is a very good article highlighting... [MORE]	jason preston	Mar 13, 2007 14:57
Could Mitt Romney be more "Christian" than Evangelicals? Of course all Protestants and Catholics subscribe to the Nicene creed, which... [MORE]	Bot	Mar 13, 2007 07:45
It's unfortunate that Mitt Romney, who's obviously a man of achievement and excellent capabilities, is being pulverized simply on account... [MORE]	virgil crespus	Mar 13, 2007 07:01

Reader comment on:How Tolerant Are We?in response to reader comment: Ask a Mormon

Other reader comments on this article

Comment on How Tolerant Are We?

Reader comment on:
How Tolerant Are We?
in response to reader comment: Ask a Mormon