The Gun Had Nothing To Do With It! - Reader comments at The New York Sun

Recent Blog Posts

Reader comment on:
A Glimpse of Evil

Submitted by CR Mountjoy, Apr 17, 2007 17:46

There is no sanity in the 'Insanity of Gun Obsession' response. The point this person misses, and most people who think like him always miss, is that there are no laws that will ever prevent any person willing to carry out an act of evil. You can outlaw guns. But if someone is motivated and organized, any plan can be carried out. So getting rid of guns is not only not possible, the argument is silly. So in the case of VT, the real issue is evil not gun control. Pure and simple, this is an act of evil as the article points out. Comparing VT to Iraq, while emotionally expedient and cathartically convenient, is not intellectually honest. We and our allies are in Iraq because of the need to respond to evil. The leap of logic to make VT and Iraq connected does not work. But to say that VT and Iraq are connected because of an obsession with guns is not true, honest or fair. Let me ask the commenter this: If we go to war because we are obsessed with guns, why are we not at a constant state of war? What about this obsession with guns you claim exists when there is no war? Is there ever peace? Absolutely, there have been long periods in our history when there was peace or an absence of war. So, the assertion that obsession with guns and sustained or individual acts of violence and their connection always being present is not logically possible. I think the commenter needs to focus on the person who committed the evil, not the choice of his instrument of that evil. This nut-case, God forbid, could have used other means to carry out his plot - more sinister, more lethal, and ‘more evil.' The issue is not an obsession with guns in this nation. The issue is that the vast majority of people who legally own guns in this nation don't shoot other people. The VT shooter was evil and committed and evil act. The gun had nothing to do with it.

Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.

Other reader comments on this article

Comment	By	Date
The Virginia Tech shootings provoke cries for draconian gun control laws enlisting wisdom from bureaucrats and politicians comparable to those... [MORE]	Nolan Nelson	Apr 21, 2007 21:22
You all are missing the point here. This is what happens when you try to limit who can own a... [MORE]	Jack Modena	Apr 29, 2007 18:01
Every time an atrocity of this nature occurs, somehow we as a nation seem to forget the loss of X... [MORE]	A Troubled American	Apr 18, 2007 18:07
We will never get rid of guns in this country. And I say that being an anti-gun person. I have... [MORE]	Garrett	Apr 18, 2007 13:51
To Ciancaglini,Garrett,Saterlee. You are living in a dream world if you thing any kind of a law would have stopped... [MORE]	Rogers Marshall	Apr 18, 2007 18:23
There is no sanity in the 'Insanity of Gun Obsession' response. The point this person misses, and most people who...	CR Mountjoy	Apr 17, 2007 17:46
Some of what I am reading about Cho today suggest he was crazy not evil. There is a difference. Unfortunately, from... [MORE]	obera	Apr 17, 2007 14:49
I find the editorial's labeling of the culprit as "evil" rather unhelpful. Certainly his acts could be labelled as evil.... [MORE]	Guy B. Jones	Apr 17, 2007 14:20
Hey, 9-11 was the biggest mass slaughter in our history...No guns were involved. [MORE]	Edmond J. Gruenenfelder	Apr 19, 2007 12:26
Although it is nearly universally accepted that there are individuals who are mentally burdened, the murdered remain murdered, and the... [MORE]	George Rivera	Apr 23, 2007 20:18
As a pediatric physician, I can tell you universal allowance of handgun possession is not the answer to the escalating... [MORE]	Doreen Ciancaglini	Apr 17, 2007 14:13
Nearly twenty years ago a woman friend of mine, staunchly anti-gun, was sitting in her boyfriend's convertible waiting for him... [MORE]	A.L.	Apr 17, 2007 13:50
If it had been a tornado in VA, they would have found a way to warn the students. It had been... [MORE]	Jay Larson	Apr 17, 2007 11:59
The constitution allows everyone the authority to own a weapon. When it was written its constructors had no way of... [MORE]	dan mckeown	Apr 30, 2007 05:30
Naturally, what we--the country with the most guns,the most murders by guns, the most weapons manufacturers and weapon sellers in... [MORE]	Don Satterlee	Apr 17, 2007 11:25
Allow me to correct Don Saterlee. Virginia Tech type incidents do not occur daily in Iraq. What does occur... [MORE]	David Eisenberg	Apr 18, 2007 12:09
>>The Second Amendment was never intended to arm violently disposed people with modern mass killing machines. Well, that is correct. The... [MORE]	Dave Blackmon	Apr 20, 2007 15:13

Reader comment on:A Glimpse of Evil

Other reader comments on this article

Comment on A Glimpse of Evil

Reader comment on:
A Glimpse of Evil