Peer "Review" = Academic "Red Lining" - Reader comments at The New York Sun

Recent Blog Posts

Reader comment on:
Mark Moyar, Historian of Vietnam, Finds Academe Hostile to a Hawk

Submitted by Max Vladimir, May 1, 2007 05:28

Prof. Moyar so far has had to deal only with employment discrimination. Next up on the Ivory Tower agenda: Sabotaging Dr. Moyar's attempts to publish scholarly articles. Publication of his articles and books will be prevented by "peers" who "review" his work and deem it not worthy of publication. Dr. Moyar's "sins" are not limited to his "philosophical" affiliations, and his conservative affiliation may be a smoke screen.

I am familiar with a "screaming liberal" who cannot get his work published because he has committed the same fundamental sin that Dr. Moyar has: He has not accepted received opinion. He has gone to the original sources, done his independent research, and has come up with conclusions that prove the "accepted authorities" to be "wrong".

Hell hath no fury like an alleged grand poobah scorned!

Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.

Other reader comments on this article

Comment	By	Date
Dr. Moyar's book on the Vietnam War is far from a revisionists work based on his reliance on primary sources.... [MORE]	raymond . roode	May 2, 2008 23:41
In as much as, Mr. Moyar's is an expert on Vietnam, the operative question here would be does UTEP have... [MORE]	t. jasper parnell	May 7, 2007 22:10
So you went to Harvard and published a book, that alone should be a guarantee of getting offered every job... [MORE]	R. Debois	May 6, 2007 13:04
UT-El Paso specializes in "borderlands" history -- specifically, the US border. It is not at all surprising (or sinister) that... [MORE]	Wilson	May 5, 2007 08:08
I want to qualify what the Sun said about my endorsement of Mark Moyar's book. The endorsement was of its... [MORE]	William Stueck	May 3, 2007 20:00
lol, whatever. The guy applies to 30 positions a year, and complains when he doesn't get a job? The teaching... [MORE]	Dan	May 3, 2007 12:04
It's very hard to get a job as a history professor. Any university that recruits for a tenure-track job in... [MORE]	Sean Campbell	May 3, 2007 11:55
In my opinion there is a greater threat to our nation and culture from bias in higher education and the... [MORE]	Geoffrey F. Weiss	May 2, 2007 16:54
Dr. Moyer's story sounds all too familiar. From my position as a lonely conservative historian within the liberal stronghold that... [MORE]	Steven E. Woodworth	May 1, 2007 11:38
This sounds familiar. Over the last 3 years I probably applied for 75 tenure track positions in history. I have... [MORE]	Antemurale	May 1, 2007 11:10
This story is all too familiar to anyone who has much experience negotiating the halls of academe. Incidentally, the Texas Tech... [MORE]	Tim Byars	May 1, 2007 09:52
Dr. Moyar's experience is unfortunately not unique. The term "intolerant liberal" is supposed to be an oxymoron, but much of... [MORE]	R J Del Vecchio	May 1, 2007 08:56
Prof. Moyar so far has had to deal only with employment discrimination. Next up on the Ivory Tower agenda: Sabotaging...	Max Vladimir	May 1, 2007 05:28
My condolences to Professor Moyar. He is indeed a victim - of a corrupt peer review system that enforces ideological... [MORE]	Arthur Pontynen	Apr 30, 2007 11:01
It's amazing the hostility Mr. Moyar encountered, despite his unique credentials. I'm wondering if these so called "professors" and "academics"... [MORE]	Constantine A. Papas	Apr 30, 2007 05:46

Reader comment on:Mark Moyar, Historian of Vietnam, Finds Academe Hostile to a Hawk

Other reader comments on this article

Comment on Mark Moyar, Historian of Vietnam, Finds Academe Hostile to a Hawk

Reader comment on:
Mark Moyar, Historian of Vietnam, Finds Academe Hostile to a Hawk