As if politics without myth-making is even possible; it will do to have a look at the use of political symbols and retorics...What do you think "human rights" are? A myth might be true, but, and that's the point, we don't know for sure...
"On what basis does a person assert that reason must be abandoned (in favor of nationalism and myth-making) in order to avoid 'nihilism'?"
a. considering the irrational, 'antagonistic' impulses of men, "the people" itself?
b. Was there ever an fully "nihilistic" policy /polity or do you know someone who can be accurately described by this term? Strauss points out, and I approve, nihilism cannot be a guide through life...
The greatest myth is "the enlightened public"; let's all deliberate, be fully rational etc. You have ever actually seen a large group of people that were guided by 'pure reason'? Who decides what can be qualified as 'reasonable', Caesar? What to do with the 'unreasonable'...?
Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.
Other reader comments on this article
Comment
By
Date
Cutting through the maze of diatribes surrounding the name "Leo Strauss," we may attempt TO UNDERSTAND THE AUTHOR AS HE... [MORE]
Marco Andreacchio
Feb 11, 2008 13:18
I have spent years reading Strauss and his contemporaries, and, as a student of Jewish philosophy, have also read Maimonides... [MORE]
Ingrid Anderson
Jun 25, 2007 13:09
I too have read (and continue to read) Leo Strauss for many years and feel that the comment by Ingrid... [MORE]
Peter
Jul 2, 2007 18:13
"driven to employ a peculiar manner of writing which would enable them to reveal what they regard as the truth... [MORE]
Riley
Feb 20, 2007 13:22
As if politics without myth-making is even possible; it will do to have a look at the use of political...