Minor error of precision - Reader comments at The New York Sun

Recent Blog Posts

Reader comment on:
Libel Suit Leads to Destruction of Books

Submitted by Charles, Aug 4, 2007 11:28

Gary's article is well laid out, but as a matter of technical (or should I say legal) precision, it is slightly incorrect to say that the people in the UK enjoy less "First Amendment protections" than in the U.S.
In fact, there is no "First Amendment" in the UK.

It would have been more precise , and what I believe that Gary meant to say, is that free speech and the press enjoy less protection than in the UK precisely because there are few barriers for punishing unpopular, or even vaguely offensive speech. The constitutional safeguards that we enjoy in the US, both substantive and procedural, are simply not available there.

Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.

Other reader comments on this article

Comment	By	Date
This book is still available online as an e-book from sites such as Mobibooks.com, which is apparently owned by Amazon.... [MORE]	Torrent Alms	Aug 5, 2007 10:24
Gary's article is well laid out, but as a matter of technical (or should I say legal) precision, it is...	Charles	Aug 4, 2007 11:28
There obviously must be something here for the Saudis to object so much. I wasn't interested in the book before,... [MORE]	Scott Slotterbeck	Aug 3, 2007 16:13
I wonder how long it'll be before suits are filed to pull this off library shelves. Just searching the NY... [MORE]	Lynn	Aug 3, 2007 09:35
"Alms for Jihad" is quickly becoming a rarity. I have already ordered my copy. It will soon be xeroxed and... [MORE]	Kurtlane	Aug 3, 2007 00:55
This cowardice, unless it is stopped now, is a foretaste of things to come. [MORE]	bob	Aug 2, 2007 18:46
It's bad enough they censor books in their own country. Not that you have to read a book to know... [MORE]	JohnnyT	Aug 2, 2007 16:35
Amazon has neither new nor used copies of Alms for Jihad on sale - though they do allow you to... [MORE]	Scott Baker	Aug 2, 2007 10:50
Clearly a message needs to be sent to the publisher. Censorship can not be tolerated. Freedom of speech must be... [MORE]	Roddy	Aug 3, 2007 01:01
I suggest that wherever possible, people should buy this book and give it to others to read! This is what... [MORE]	Chaya	Aug 2, 2007 10:00

Reader comment on:Libel Suit Leads to Destruction of Books

Other reader comments on this article

Comment on Libel Suit Leads to Destruction of Books

Reader comment on:
Libel Suit Leads to Destruction of Books