Submitted by Peter Knight, Dec 1, 2006 14:16

Did you even pay attention to the film? "Shocking the audience into action with appaling behavior" is truly an allegation that does not ring true to this film at its core and leads me to question your critical skills. I found it took a considerably more subtle approach than you suggest, and to a effective degree. I realize we are aloud to have a difference of opinion, but perhaps the film was too challenging for you to grasp in its totality? I hate to be so frank, but your criticisms are vague and stabby ("say nothing very beautifully..) and I dont think you find the time to tackle the film its true elements.

Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.