great - Reader comments at The New York Sun

Reader comment on:
Giuliani Calls Idea of Quitting Iraq ‘Terrible Mistake'

Submitted by Mary, Dec 7, 2006 15:09

I love when a politican can see reality. It is such a rare quality. Maybe he can run with Joe Lieberman who technically is not a democrat anymore. Lieberman also said we have to figure out how to win in iraq, a subject the Baker "think" group forgot about.

I for one am tired of Jews being scapegoated. Way to go Rudy.

Is Rudy short for Rudolph? That would be a first for a president.

Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.

Other reader comments on this article

Comment

Date

Giuliani said we should win the war and define victory. Such nonsense illustrates what is wrong with the positions of... [MORE]

Thomas

Aug 12, 2007 22:58

Israel is the buzz word that 6.5 million Jews in NYC respond to as though someone made a crack about... [MORE]

Sir Joshua

Dec 8, 2006 07:52

I agree with Guiliani and with you about Iraq but why the anti-Israel rhetoric? The Jewish Agency for Palestine decided,... [MORE]

Abu Nudnik

Dec 10, 2006 14:29

Quitting Iraq is absolutely wrong. Iran and Syria are ready to move in, and when that happens the whole region... [MORE]

Peter Kottaras

Dec 10, 2006 23:35

Mr. Giuliani is at odds with reality. To "win" in Iraq, another 400,000 troops would need to be fielded and... [MORE]

Joe

Dec 7, 2006 17:55

I'm a Christian, and fairly conservative, but I I don't want to live in a theocracy. Unfortunately from what I... [MORE]

S. O'Hara

Dec 7, 2006 17:12

Do you really think that the Israel-Palestine conflict is not tied to other issues in the Middle East? If you... [MORE]

Chris

Dec 7, 2006 15:55

I love when a politican can see reality. It is such a rare quality. Maybe he can run with Joe...

Mary

Dec 7, 2006 15:09

Rudy shows by his comments that although he's not rigidly stuck to one approach, he gets the big picture. I'm... [MORE]

Jane

Dec 7, 2006 14:30

I'd vote for Rudy in a heartbeat. Giuliani is 'action man' first, not a politician. His visceral response to 9/11... [MORE]

Sir Joshua

Dec 8, 2006 07:42

Very level-headed assessment of the entire problem of islamofacism. He's got my vote if he runs on '08. [MORE]

Paul

Dec 7, 2006 10:17

Thank G-d, one politician has the wisdom to say the right thing regarding Iraq and Israel, and the courage to... [MORE]

Yosef Keller

Dec 7, 2006 09:38

I agree with your comments, but is it too much to actually spell the word God? What's with the dash,... [MORE]

Bob Sirovatka

Dec 8, 2006 00:42

My own guess is by 2008 the public will not want to hear anymore about Iraq, certainly not about staying... [MORE]

Earl Evleth

Dec 7, 2006 09:14

There is a difference between Rudy & thoughtful critics, like Biden & MaCain of the Baker Commission report. The other... [MORE]

Anon

Dec 7, 2006 09:07

Today, December 7, 2006, we honor the 65th anniversary of The Day of Infamy. Japan's attack on Pearl Harbor demonstrates... [MORE]

Art

Dec 7, 2006 12:42

Someone is finely telling the truth. Mr. Giuliani knows what is going on. You people need to read the Bible... [MORE]

chuck

Dec 7, 2006 07:11

This country has done nothing but surrender since WWII. Eisenhower put Korea on hold - so they could build nuclear... [MORE]

Victor Galindo

Dec 7, 2006 22:34

Let's put the partisan crap aside and look at the facts. Iraq did not attack us. Saddam Hussein did not have WMDs... [MORE]

Kendall Morse

Sep 18, 2007 09:13

Comment on Giuliani Calls Idea of Quitting Iraq ‘Terrible Mistake'

Reader comment on:Giuliani Calls Idea of Quitting Iraq ‘Terrible Mistake'

Other reader comments on this article

Comment on Giuliani Calls Idea of Quitting Iraq ‘Terrible Mistake'

Reader comment on:
Giuliani Calls Idea of Quitting Iraq ‘Terrible Mistake'