Huck Tax - rest of story. Its lunacy - Reader comments at The New York Sun

Recent Blog Posts

Reader comment on:
On Taxes, Huckabee Leads

Submitted by Mark Douglas, Jan 13, 2008 11:31

I hope the FAIRTAX passes. It will be laughed at for 100 years. What research was done on it? Did anyone ask the military (cause they have to tax even government consumption) what they will do if suddenly all their ammuntion, guns, jets, submarines, and Krations cost 23% more?

Did they call even one nursing home, to ask what they would do when they have to raise prices 23% on their patients? Did they call any cancer patients, and ask what they would do when their chemo and doctor bill have a 23% tax? Did they call any renters to ask what they would do if they suddenly had to pay 23% extra?

Or on the response of cancer patients, when they get 23% tax on chemo? Or reponse of nursing home patients when the get a 23% increase?

Did they call the Realtor lobby, and ask what they would do when new homes were taxed 23%? Did they ask the the home builder lobby what they would do?

I know what these folks would do -- they would scream bloody murder, demand - and get - exemptions. Cancer patients wont have to pay the tax, I guarantee it. The military wont either, same guarantee. Realtor lobby, same thing. No person in their right mind would buy a 300K new home, when it would cost them closer to 400,000. They would just buy a used home.

As one exemption was granted after another -- the 23% would mushroom to 30-40-50.

Reseach that. And you research that by calling a few nursing homes, and asking. Call a few cancer patients, and ask them. Call military budget experts--ask them what they would do if suddenly they had to pay 23% tax on a tank,a jet, sonar, Humvee?

Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.

Other reader comments on this article

Comment	By	Date
I hope the FAIRTAX passes. It will be laughed at for 100 years. What research was done on it? Did...	Mark Douglas	Jan 13, 2008 11:31
When I first heard about the fairtax, I shared the same concerns as you, until I went to fairtax.org and... [MORE]	Doug	Jan 17, 2008 10:57
What research. I read the book. I looked at all the material I could. I didnt see ANY research. WHy?... [MORE]	Mark	Jan 17, 2008 22:43
ron paul wants to get rid of the irs ,can it be any better than that!!!!!ron paul wants enforce the... [MORE]	the truth is good	Dec 12, 2007 11:00
I wish to commend your paper for being the first I have seen to make fair and balanced comments on... [MORE]	Jim Bennett	Dec 7, 2007 18:28
The Fair Tax is a horrible compromise. It does nothing to decrease government spending, hurts the middle class, benefits the... [MORE]	Paul Weber	Dec 8, 2007 01:22
Paul, I partially agree with your first comment that the Fair Tax does nothing for spending. However when the cost of... [MORE]	Jim Bennett	Dec 8, 2007 07:48
It is without a doubt the most refreshing and principled stand by a Presidential candidate that I have ever witnessed... [MORE]	Jeffrey Locke	Dec 7, 2007 18:12
I have this to say in defense of the FAIR TAX, HR 25 / S 1025............................Mike Huckabee's Fair Tax that... [MORE]	John Paul McDaniel	Dec 7, 2007 17:22
Sir, I am also a Texan (by way of UT Austin) and am a large supporter of Mr. Huckabee and his... [MORE]	Jeff Gillingham	Dec 8, 2007 18:09
Too much is made of the way the actual cost of the tax is figured. It basically all comes out... [MORE]	Jeff Wangsgard	Dec 9, 2007 12:33
When business buy supplies to produce their product or service, they pay no fairtax, thus lowering the cost they Fairtax... [MORE]	Jack Metzel	Dec 13, 2007 16:15
Look at page 148 of the Fair Tax book. It says the government "is itself a major taxpayer" and that... [MORE]	Mark	Jan 17, 2008 22:38
Don't trust him, he's a populist wacko [MORE]	Jonas	Dec 7, 2007 15:38
The FairTax is nothing more than a plan for a huge shift of the tax burden from the wealthiest to... [MORE]	FairTaxFraud	Dec 7, 2007 12:17
Can any one who has truthfully studied the FairTax....even with the few flaws it has...honestley say that keeping the system... [MORE]	Jeff Wangsgard	Dec 8, 2007 10:57
I wish fairtaxfraud had listed just what his vested interest in the current tax system is. Those with something to... [MORE]	Tom Kropewnicki	Dec 9, 2007 11:39
David Trueck's article is absolutely on point. One can only hope that smart voters will reward Governor Huckabee for having... [MORE]	Dan Mastromarco	Dec 7, 2007 11:38
Wow, I hardly know what to say. As a FairTax proponent I have spent the last couple of weeks playing... [MORE]	David Boone	Dec 7, 2007 17:24
The Club for Growth (Club for Greed) would have ran negative ads against Ronald Reagan - Mike Huckabee is the candidate... [MORE]	Liz	Dec 7, 2007 08:37