Submitted by John Rvert, Jan 14, 2008 06:26

Yes, we're always (we, the critics) calling Manning a choker. Why? Because he's 7 wins, 7 losses in the playoffs. that's why!! Don't give me excuses (the defense blowing it, tipped balls, etc). It was Manning's fault alone. Take a look at the last two Manning drives...each of which might have, Brady-like, rescued the Colts. Manning was terrible. Passes not even close to players, or bad reads and sent to the wrong (covered) players. Brady is what? 13-2 in playoffs? And, since it's always a Barra staple (the various excuses and Manning apologiae) one should point out that Brady didn't blame his defense, his lack of pass-catching studs. No, he just won 3 Superbowls. SO...HOW IS MANNING THE GREATEST OF THE 21ST CENTURY???? Statistics (Cold Hard Football Facts) don't lie. Manning, with all his weapons, 1 title. BRADY 3...or is it 4?

Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.