Recent Blog Posts

Fire Gonzales?

Editorial of The New York Sun | March 13, 2007

Some kind of footnote has to be offered in respect of Senator Schumer's call for President Bush to fire Attorney General Gonzales. Mr. Schumer fetched up with this brainstorm Sunday in an appearance on CBS's "Face the Nation," hours after the New York Times struck upon the same thought in an editorial in its Sunday edition. The thing to bear in mind in respect of these startling developments is that neither the Times nor Senator Schumer ever thought Mr. Gonzales should have been the attorney general to begin with. Mr. Schumer thought his confirmation would put a dagger through the heart of the Constitution, and he was among the 36 senators who voted against. The Times ran out an editorial before the confirmation vote, headlined "The Wrong Attorney General" and the day afterward declared that the confirmation vote was "depressing" and that "Mr. Gonzales was a bad choice for attorney general." So the latest round of calls for Mr. Gonzales to resign have nothing to do with his performance as attorney general. The ones, like Senator Schumer and the New York Times, calling for his resignation now didn't think he should be holding the office before he had even spent a minute on the job.


Reader comments on this article

Comment By Date

If there is any solace or hope for the American public, the forced removal of Attorney General Gonzales will be... [MORE]

J.T. Scott 

Mar 13, 2007 06:39

In your attempt to attach Senator Schumer, you might have offerred one rational for saying AG Gonzales did not do... [MORE]

pgl 

Mar 13, 2007 18:50

Even the NY Times had the courage to denounce Bill Clinton's Lewinsky scandal. The NRO appears to have lost its... [MORE]

Roger 

Mar 13, 2007 21:47

I find it ironic that the Sun thinks the fact that the Times & Senator Schumer were right about how... [MORE]

Jerry Skurnik 

Mar 13, 2007 09:04

The logic of this editorial is sophomoric. [MORE]

John 

Mar 13, 2007 12:32

Or maye the TImes, Schumer and the 36 other senators were right...isn't the Attorney General's job to serve the legal... [MORE]

Robin Bates 

Mar 13, 2007 11:04

Your logic is a little fuzzy.... Because Senator Schumer and the New York Times didn't agree with the selection of Alberto... [MORE]

Dave Kaune 

Mar 13, 2007 11:42