CONTACT US   SUBSCRIBE   PREMIUM   ADVERTISING

81F Hi 78F
Lo 66F

Recent Blog Posts

The Real Belligerents

Editorial of The New York Sun | October 26, 2007

The front-runner in the campaign for the Democratic presidential nomination, Senator Clinton, yesterday reacted to the Bush administration's announcement of tough new sanctions on the regime in Tehran with the statement, "I've been concerned for a long time over George Bush's saber rattling and belligerence toward Iran."

One wonders exactly how long. If Mrs. Clinton was concerned about it, she kept it to herself during her February 1, 2007 speech to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee. Then, she said, "U.S. policy must be clear and unequivocal. We cannot, we should not, we must not, permit Iran to build or acquire nuclear weapons. And in dealing with this threat as I have said for a very long time, no option can be taken off the table." She said, "we need to use every tool at our disposal including diplomatic and economic in addition to the threatened use of military force."

She didn't mention her concern about Mr. Bush's supposed belligerence when she appeared at a pro-Israel rally in New York on July 17, 2006, and referred to the Iranian-backed terrorist groups Hamas and Hezbollah as "the new totalitarians of the 21st century."

In fact, while Mrs. Clinton may claim that she has been concerned "for a very long time" about Mr. Bush's supposed belligerence, she's only started talking about it recently, in an attempt to pander to hard-left Democratic caucus-goers and primary voters. As Mrs. Clinton doubtless understands, the real belligerents in the conflict between America and the terror-sponsoring, nuclear bomb-building, Holocaust-denying government of Iran are the Iranians, not President Bush.

Any suggestion to the contrary is blurring an important national security issue for partisan political advantage. It puts Mrs. Clinton out of step with her party's leaders on foreign policy issues, such as the chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, Thomas Lantos, who yesterday issued a statement commending President Bush for imposing the sanctions and calling for even tougher measures. Mrs. Clinton runs the risk of being used as propaganda echo-chamber by an Iranian government eager to portray America as the aggressor. It's not only irresponsible, but, in light of Mrs. Clinton's previous statements, difficult to subject to a charitable interpretation.


Reader comments on this article

Comment By Date

Don't be suprised when she flip flops on this subject like she does all the others.

[MORE]

al collins 

Oct 27, 2007 18:47

It figures that Hillary Rodham Clinton will say ANYTHING, do ANYTHING, be ANYTHING to everyone in the hope of attaining... [MORE]

emily mettel 

Oct 27, 2007 13:30

Why am I seeing Jimmy Carter all over again?

[MORE]

Nancy 

Oct 27, 2007 07:22

This is the most important thing to her. She sees that this stand is what the majority of the country... [MORE]

Richard Clark 

Oct 27, 2007 00:06

It is long past time to talk to Iran. We may have major disagreements, but should not contemplate military action.... [MORE]

R T Carpenter 

Oct 27, 2007 00:02

Hillary will do or say anything, no matter how egregious to get what she wants. Talking out of both sides... [MORE]

Carol Vitucci 

Oct 26, 2007 09:33

Comment on this article

    Before submitting your comment, please provide a valid email address to complete the verification process.

    Fall Education
    A New York Sun Advertorial Section

    NEW YORK ›

    Report: Real Estate Subsidies Draining City Coffers

    City: Staten Island Man Dead From West Nile Virus

    Arrest Furthers a Real Estate Star's Fall

    Big Increase in Unemployment Could Tax State's Resources

    State Finds Labor Violations At Saratoga Race Track

    City Taps Another Strength, Wins Drinking Water Contest

    NATIONAL ›

    Gustav's Path Prompts New Orleans Evacuation Talk

    McCain Denies He's Selected a Running Mate

    Feds Take Over Probe of Alleged Obama Threat

    'Obama Is the Man for This Job'

    Drama on Floor as Clinton Cuts Roll Call Vote

    Al-Arian Files Habeas for Release

    ARTS+ ›

    Political Ephemera Through the Ages

    The Art World Embraces the Wow Factor

    To Venice: Some Unsolicited Advice

    A Bronx Tale: Tony Curtis

    Pasolini's Cruel Masterpiece

    Takashi Miike's Crime Wave