Recent Blog Posts

Goodnight, Moondance

By GARY SHAPIRO, Staff Reporter of the Sun | February 13, 2007

On the western frontier of SoHo, the Moondance Diner is dancing off into the sunset: Along with an adjacent two-story parking garage and a parking lot, it is going to be developed into luxury residential condominiums.

Click Image to Enlarge

Konrad Fiedler

Residential condominiums will be built at the site of the Moondance Diner on Sixth Avenue.

The Moondance Diner's incandescent, crescent-shaped sign is a beacon for hungry visitors roaming north of Canal Street amid a Hopper-esque landscape not far from the mouth of the Holland Tunnel. The late-night watering hole has appeared in episodes of "Friends" and "Sex and the City," and it was where Peter Parker's girlfriend, Mary Jane, played by Kirsten Dunst, waited tables in the 2002 film "Spider-Man." In real life, playwright Jonathan Larson ("Rent") worked at the diner.

The development is among several changes taking place in the neighborhood, which is characterized by low-slung buildings along Sixth Avenue that are attracting private investment. "SoHo'sdevelopment is moving westward," the director of the SoHo Alliance, a neighborhood organization, Sean Sweeney, said. The site of a former Mobil gas station farther north, at Spring Street, is also slated for development. About a block west, Donald Trump Jr. has plans for a 45-story condominium. An executive director of Eastern Consolidated, Eric Anton, who was a broker of the Moondance site, said the property was up for sale for about three months until the owners — a joint venture that includes developer Gary Barnett — decided to develop it themselves. Calls yesterday to Extell Development Corporation, which is headed by Mr. Barnett, were not returned. Mr. Barnett is also assembling a site three blocks north at 176 Avenue of the Americas, where a Sleepy's store is situated.

"There are not going to be any more diners," the owner of Moondance Diner, Sunil "Sunny" Sharma, said. Inside the narrow restaurant, black-and-white photos of Yankees stars greet customers who come to enjoy milkshakes, handcut fries, homemade buttermilk onion rings, and burgers. The food is priced a bit higher than one might expect at a diner: Cole slaw is $2.95. He plans to discuss the possibility of opening the Moondance Diner anew on the commercial first floor of the residential building. In the meantime, he plans to hold on to the Moondance sign.

A representative of Hudson Island LLC, the owner of the property, told The New York Sun ground will be broken this year and the current buildings razed. He said plans for the property, which is about 11,330 square feet and may be as tall as nine stories, were still being finalized, and that the Board of Standards and Appeals had approved the plans to build a 66,734-square-foot residential building there.

Dick Blodgett of the Charlton Street Block Association did not comment on this building, but said the community is concerned that large buildings such as the one Mr. Trump is constructing at Spring and Varick streets are "outside the scale of the neighborhood." A member of the Van Dam Street Block Association, Silvia Beame, said, "We don't want to see the area become overdeveloped."

Mr. Anton described the western part of SoHo as "in my mind, a more attractive place to live" than the center of SoHo, which can be crowded on the weekends. He said that being a little bit on the edge of SoHo is very attractive. Mr. Sweeney said he is concerned about a continuing trend of losing parking spaces and adding buildings with more residents.

The executive director of the BSA, Jeff Mulligan, said the owners of the Moondance site received a variance for residential use. The city planning department spokeswoman said the area is ordinarily zoned for light manufacturing.

For the near future, hungry tourists and residents will be able to continue enjoying the Moondance Diner, whose seats run along a corridor on which the words "Eat Here" are writ large. Mr. Sharma said he had his wedding celebration about five years ago at the diner. Come next year, instead of enjoying the food, new residents in the condominium may have to settle for kicking up their heels to Van Morrison's "Moondance":

"Well, it's a marvelous night for a moondance
With the stars up above in your eyes
A fantabulous night to make romance
'neath the cover of October skies."


Reader comments on this article

Read all comments

Comment By Date

Some say the only thing constant is change "nothing is forever". New York real estate is every escalating with property... [MORE]

Ed Haynes 

Feb 13, 2007 16:44

As a RENT fan. I can't be more than angry this has (if it happened, im not sure) taken place.... [MORE]

Roxy Collins 

Jun 29, 2007 23:39

The only establishments that can afford to be in these condo developments are the Duane Reades and Starbucks'. My neighborhood... [MORE]

Keithrez 

Feb 14, 2007 09:05

I have to say that hearing the news of Moondance being torn down is extremely depressing to me. This is... [MORE]

Amanda Laforet 

Feb 25, 2007 22:51

Thediner is a historic landmark. We cannot allow something so historic to be torn down for the overpriced new york... [MORE]

Danielle 

Feb 26, 2007 04:43

I am a young worker at the production facility next door to the Moondance diner, and feel that this establishment... [MORE]

Kyle 

Feb 27, 2007 13:05

That's good thinking. And it's nice to hear from someone who's right there near the site. I don't know any... [MORE]

Sara 

Feb 28, 2007 14:19

How dare anyone tear down such a landmark. I think it would be a disgrace if they tore it down... [MORE]

kim Herndonm 

Feb 26, 2007 14:39

Is there anything being done to try to stop this? There's got to be something that can be done! At... [MORE]

Sara 

Feb 27, 2007 07:51

We Rentheads and every other person out there needs to get involved and become active in Saving Moondance. It would... [MORE]

Kim Herndon 

Feb 27, 2007 11:23

How can people be SO heartless as to tear down this beautiful monument, not only to New York, but to... [MORE]

Sami 

Feb 27, 2007 11:53

Is anything being done? If not, we need to start something immediately. I may be in Texas but we have... [MORE]

Sara 

Feb 27, 2007 21:01

How can you tear it down?! This sounds a little close to RENT. Tearing down this landmark in lue of... [MORE]

Paul 

Feb 27, 2007 16:22

Paul, the author of RENT was actually the manager there at Moondance while he wrote it. [MORE]

Tim 

Mar 6, 2007 14:06

Real estate developers are rapidly replacing lawyers as the butt of jokes about soullessness. Hasn't it occurred to them that... [MORE]

Laurence Cantor 

Mar 3, 2007 09:01

I have been to the Moondance Diner. The first time was because I am a RENTHead, and I just had... [MORE]

Sarah 

Mar 5, 2007 16:23

Because I designed the logo for my friend and former owner of the Moondance, Larry. I remember how Larry had... [MORE]

Tim 

Mar 6, 2007 13:58

This is so not fair! I'm a huge renthead, and I've always wanted to go to the Moondance diner to... [MORE]

Chelsea 

Mar 6, 2007 15:37

This place mixed up the greatest Rum and Tabs in the business.......BEST banana pancakes in the business....and burgers. Found... [MORE]

rick benko 

Mar 7, 2007 09:34

Larry Pannish.............a friend for 30 years.........owned the moondance. Michael J. Fox was part of our RISK games at the moondance.... [MORE]

Darryl Rolandelli 

Mar 6, 2007 18:44

I have spoken to the owner, a man named Sunis. He wants to save the diner, but seems to not... [MORE]

Kyle 

Mar 14, 2007 10:32

How dare they! The moondance is a historic place in Broadway theatre! Jonathan Larson, the creator of RENT, worked there!... [MORE]

Mimi 

Mar 15, 2007 19:59

This is one of the memories of Jonathan Larson.No way can they tear it down.I can't even write down how... [MORE]

MaryKate 

Mar 19, 2007 18:45

Greetings Diner Fans! I sympathize with your recent comments. I take pride in informing you that an art auction/fundraiser to... [MORE]

Michael 

May 2, 2007 04:33

Is anyone really suprised? CBGB, Wetlands, The Palladium, the Garage, 2ND AVE Diner, HARLEM (altogether), Empire Rink...! This is nothing... [MORE]

Corey 

May 10, 2007 12:23

Powered by Inform

RELATED SUN TOPICS ›

RELATED SUN STORIES ›