Recent Blog Posts

Residential Parking Permits May Accompany Congestion Tax

By ANNIE KARNI, Special to the Sun | May 7, 2007

With six weeks to win support for its proposed traffic tax, the Bloomberg administration is trying to sweeten its proposal to charge drivers a fee for using Manhattan's busiest streets during peak hours. The city is considering offering residential parking permits in certain neighborhoods, curtailing the number of government parking permits it issues to city workers, and offering express bus service in districts where lawmakers oppose the driver fee.

Residential parking permits could be established in Brooklyn Heights, Upper Manhattan, Long Island City, and other neighborhoods surrounding Manhattan's central business district — a concession to those communities that would discourage drivers from approaching the edges of tolled Manhattan and clogging up their streets to avoid paying the $8 congestion fee.

The city in the past has opposed residential parking permits on the basis that visitors would be unable to find parking. Permit parking has been used for years in cities such as Boston and Washington. In those cities, cars without permits can park for two hours or less.

Another option the city is studying is building "Park and Ride" facilities near train stations, local officials said.

The city's Department of Transportation is also conducting a block-by-block survey of parking patterns below Canal Street, and studying government parking placard use and abuse, an agency spokesman said.

Eliminating free parking for city employees would take about 19,000 car trips off the city 's streets annually, according to statistics provided by the advocacy group Transportation Alternatives. That number represents about a third of the total anticipated reduction in traffic that could be achieved through congestion pricing. A spokesman for the mayor, John Gallagher, said it was still too early to say how many placards Mr. Bloomberg could remove from the streets, or how the city would increase its enforcement.

The Partnership for New York City has recommended to the city that it rein in the number of government parking permits it issues, and enforce that the permits are used only for official government business, the president and CEO of the Partnership, Kathryn Wylde, said.

Cracking down on placard abuse would reduce traffic congestion in Lower Manhattan and could help win the support of the Assembly speaker, Sheldon Silver, who represents the district, sources said.

"Lower Manhattan cannot be one big parking lot for government workers with parking placards," Council Member Alan Gerson, who represents the neighborhood, said in an interview yesterday. The city currently issues about 150,000 parking placards, which Mr. Gerson said was "far too many for the amount of parking we have available."

About 37% of government workers drive into the city, as compared with 5% of New York City residents overall. "They're out of touch with how normal New Yorkers travel," the executive director of Transportation Alternatives, Paul Steely White, said.

A spokesman said the police department has cut back the number of placards it issues to its staff by about 20% since Commissioner Raymond Kelly was appointed in 2002.


Reader comments on this article

Comment By Date

One statistic ignored by everyone in the studies being used to justify the $8 entry tax is that 10-15% of... [MORE]

El Jefe 

May 7, 2007 10:21

How can you call congestion pricing a tax? It's a fee charged to users of a facility, so that users... [MORE]

Steve 

May 7, 2007 10:54

Finally, a person with reason added something to this debate. Thank you Steve! Your post "Not a Tax," hits the... [MORE]

eddie 

May 11, 2007 14:06

New York really is finished. [MORE]

Andrew 

May 7, 2007 17:07

Before this congestion fee issue existed, there was illegal parking and parking permit abuse (and of course it still exists),... [MORE]

Stop illegal placard parking 

May 7, 2007 18:23

What do they do? They have small children and they are not going to take the LIRR and a bus... [MORE]

Minverva 

May 7, 2007 18:41

Park and ride has always happened. I do it every day. I drive from one part of Queens to another... [MORE]

Krystian 

Mar 19, 2008 23:07

Bloomberg must be really feeling pressure to offer this concession. I study parking and residential permits work very well in... [MORE]

Erik Feder - The Parking Expert 

May 8, 2007 09:11

Everyone posting here, putting forth their "wisdom" for solving the parking problem here in New York City, particularly in Manhattan,... [MORE]

W. H. Injeian 

May 11, 2007 09:55

Traffic to (and through) downtown Brooklyn has grown tremendously over the past ten years. It is expected that traffic will... [MORE]

Jo Anne Simon 

May 8, 2007 12:55

I agree 100% with Residential Parking Permit. I live in Brooklyn on a residential street, we have lived in our... [MORE]

M.C. Shell 

May 10, 2007 01:11

If they try to instill residential parking--then are my taxes going to go down--why should my tax pay for these... [MORE]

scotty 

Jun 12, 2007 08:16

Consider permit parking for the Park Slope area. There is rarely available parking near my home and it is worse... [MORE]

M.Farrell 

Mar 20, 2008 10:17