Recent Blog Posts

Teacher Pay Fails To Affect Scores, Report Says

By SARAH GARLAND, Staff Reporter of the Sun | January 31, 2007

Student test scores are not better in cities where teachers are paid more than other white-collar workers, a report released today says.

A senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, Jay Green, who co-wrote the study, said the findings don't contradict arguments in support of merit pay for teachers, a system that financially rewards teachers whose students perform better on standardized tests.

The study, which used U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics data from 2005, showed only that simply paying teachers more makes no difference, he said.

After comparing wages for teachers with other workers in 66 cities, researchers also found that teachers often make significantly more than workers in other professions, including public relations specialists, reporters, and economists.

"I think we have a popular fantasy that teachers are paid like fast food workers, but when we look at the evidence they're paid better than most other white-collar workers," Mr. Green said.


Reader comments on this article

Comment By Date

Achievement will always be low until decisions concerning education include teachers! Like any and every profession you had the good... [MORE]

T. Richardson 

Jan 31, 2007 18:30

When a person can receive civil service and union protection, coupled with days off, mandatory breaks and a pension, in... [MORE]

Alfred Marellazo 

Feb 5, 2007 16:15

First off, to wit on the "humongous" benefits I supposedly receive as a teacher in the public school system: I... [MORE]

Warren Phillips 

Feb 6, 2007 14:47

Their pay is huge (check out Connecticut and Alaska) while their work time if minimal. On top of that they... [MORE]

kiwikit 

Jan 31, 2007 18:57

As I stated before, but the moderator decided to censor my post, Jay Green's report is a lot of half-truths... [MORE]

The dude 

Feb 1, 2007 21:42

Teachers now do actually make decent money. I enjoy reading that they spend minimal time working and 'ease into retirement.'... [MORE]

English Teacher 

Feb 2, 2007 13:21

In the hard sciences, reports gain credence when they appear in peer-reviewed publications. Since the Manhattan Institute -- a think... [MORE]

Paul Schickler 

Feb 6, 2007 23:56