The Force Behind Two Columbus Circle

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

Holly Hotchner is a Renaissance woman who believes that acquiring knowledge obligates action.

The director of the Museum of Arts and Design learned about Classical art in Europe. She learned to restore 16th century Italian paintings from the master John Brealey. She learned to ride horses at a French circus training school in Normandy. She learned about the history of the Roman Catholic Church during travels across Europe. She learned art history at Trinity College in Connecticut. She learned about business when she and her sister, Tracy Hotchner, opened a hot dog stand when they were children.



She learned about Hemingway’s literary technique from the great writer himself by way of her father, A. E. Hotchner, who was the Nobel laureate’s friend and biographer.

She learned about museum administration while working for the legendary Thomas Hoving at the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

She learned about pentimento when she climbed the scaffoldings at the Sistine Chapel to study the restoration of Michelangelo’s masterpieces. She practiced conservation of painting at London’s venerable Tate Gallery.

She learned about preservation of old documents and then helped archive 5 million of them at the New-York Historical Society.

Then she learned about consulting when she started her own business.

“I then discovered that I needed to do something else,” Ms. Hotchner said. “I like tough challenges, and I like problem solving.”

In 1996, she became director of the Museum of Arts and Design. Ms. Hotchner soon learned about the complexity of New York City politics, when she encountered tough opposition to the museum’s purchase of Two Columbus Avenue, a landmark building that she wanted to transform into a center for the arts.

“The challenge at the museum was whether it was providing what people really wanted,” Ms. Hotchner said.

Before she could address that large question, she had to attend to minor details – such as meeting the payroll.

“For 15 weeks, the museum couldn’t even make the payroll,” Ms. Hotchner said. “The staff was totally demoralized. The museum had no plan.

“I wanted the museum to become an energetic center for the arts for the Upper West Side, a meeting place for all who are interested in contemporary life and the multiple expressions of craft and design today,” she said. “I saw the museum as a global crossroads in New York for the meaning of objects worldwide.

“As a born New Yorker – who had been given so much by this city – I saw it as a life dream to be able to create an institution that would endure and pass to new generations the power to enrich lives through the appreciation of objects. I wanted the museum to be a unique institution representing thousands of artists around the globe who, through their vision and skills, transform materials and enhance lives,” she said.

The museum’s board president, Nan Laitman, endorsed Ms. Hotchner’s vision and, indeed,put up the initial money for the new museum. The board chairwoman, Barbara Tober, was similarly supportive. The philanthropist and former chief executive officer of Liz Claiborne Incorporated, Jerry Chazen, offered to run the fund-raising and building campaign.

“The Edward Durell Stone building became the poster child for issues such as how contemporary architecture can be dealt with in the landmarking system,” Ms. Hotchner said. “It became a center of controversy. I now know more about real estate law than I ever want to know. And to think that I went into this as an art historian. The lawsuits delayed the project by three to five years. And even though we won all those lawsuits, the funders became worried.”

The worry had to do mostly with the escalating cost of rehabilitating and renovating the building. The original budget of $50 million climbed to $85 million, of which the purchase price was $17 million. Ms. Hotchner said about $20 million still needs to be raised. The new facility is expected to be ready in early 2008.

Designed by Edward Durell Stone in 1964, Two Columbus Circle originally housed the Huntington Hartford Gallery of Contemporary Art. Fairleigh Dickinson University operated the New York Cultural Center in the building from 1969 to 1975.

In 1976, Gulf & Western Industries purchased the building and gave it to the city to serve as a visitor center and headquarters for the Cultural Affairs Department. The agency moved out in 1998 and the building remained vacant since then. Indeed, the building had been unusable for more than half its life.

Ms. Hotchner said that when the museum moves to Columbus Circle, its space will more than triple, to 54,000 square feet from 17,000 square feet in its present location at 40 E. 53rd St. For the first time since its founding in 1956, the museum will be able to present and expand its permanent collection of more than 1,700 art objects, including ceramics, fiber, glass, metal, paper, wood, mixed media, and design. It is “one of the most distinguished collections of its kind in the world,” Ms. Hotchner said.

“The museum celebrates materials and processes that are today embraced by practitioners in the fields of craft, art, and design, as well as architecture, fashion, interior design, technology, performing arts, and art- and design driven industries.

“I truly believe that culture enriches people’s minds,” Ms. Hotchner said. “Our programs for children are outstanding and meaningful. What we’re doing at the museum is demystifying contemporary art and design by showing how it’s made. We’re showing how technology interfaces with hand work. Accessibility and approachability are important to us. I feel that we are expanding the very meaning of a museum.

“And one of the reasons that I see this as such an exciting moment is that this generation is so involved with lifestyle – lifestyle that has so much to do with contemporary arts and design.”


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use