Is Nothing Sacred at Washington?
The Biden administration wants to tell the Jewish state how to run its Holocaust memorial.
American intervention in Israelâs internal matters was once thought to be a rare thing. Now the Biden administration is openly opining on the Jewish stateâs efforts at judicial reform and transparently hoping that Prime Minister Netanyahu will lose his grip on the premiership. To that meddling add interference by the administration in respect of who directs Yad Vashem, Israelâs Holocaust Museum. Is nothing sacred at Washington?
Yad Vashem, perched on a slope of Mount Herzl, is an important institution. It dates to 1953. It is, after the Western Wall, also at Jerusalem, the most visited site in the Jewish state. Its director, Dani Dayan, is a political appointee. Mr. Dayan, though, was appointed not by Mr. Netanyahu but by the previous government, which Mr. Netanyahu defeated in the last election. Israelâs education minister, Yoav Kisch, has tried to remove Mr. Dayan.
It is not for us to determine the justness of that. Mr. Kisch alleges mismanagement. Mr. Dayan claims raw politics tied to the judicial overhaul, and has threatened to take the matter to Mr Netanyahuâs political arch-foe, Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara. The American Society for Yad Vashem â another distinguished institution â claims that Mr. Dayan is trying to âraidâ the Societyâs finances and is seeking its endowment of $80 million.
The society, in a letter to Yad Vashem, writes that since Mr. Dayan âassumed the Chairmanship of the Yad Vashem Directorate, we have been troubled by his repeated and significant exercises of bad judgment, disregard of past written agreements, disdain for legal requirements.â It cites âlack of transparency and manipulations of Yad Vashemâs decision making process.â The society warns of âever increasing belligerence and threats.â
At the least, the correspondence suggests that Mr. Kischâs concerns over Mr. Dayan might not be entirely unfounded. Yet now comes Americaâs antisemitism envoy, Deborah Lipstadt, tweeting that âYad Vashemâs painstaking and invaluable research on the Shoah is in no small part due to its professionalism and independence.â An envoy for Holocaust Issues, Ellen Germain, writes that maintaining the âindependenceâ of such institutions is âkey.â
These Biden administration officials were joined by the European Unionâs coordinator on antisemitism, Katharina von Schnurbein. She tweeted that the museumâs âexpertise and independence of its leadership are essential in times of Holocaust distortion.â Those all read to us like a warning. One not without chutzpah, coming from the Europeans. Why isnât our State Department springing to defend the decisions of Israelâs democracy?
Weâve long since concluded that it was just a mistake for America to put an antisemitism envoy into the State Department in the first place. It was from the start only a matter of time before such an officer started telling Israel how to run its affairs. Plus, too, we had to watch the administration start hedging on a definition of the worldâs oldest hatred. Congress could have legislated a blunt definition before underwriting an envoy.
It turns out, according to the Times of Israel, that âamid a growing outcry over alleged attempts by Prime Minister Netanyahuâs government to oustâ Mr. Dayan, âunnamed senior officialsâ believe he will stay. In other words, hectoring by President Bidenâs camarilla stayed Mr. Netanyahuâs hand. We have little doubt that similar efforts are afoot in respect of, say, the Iran nuclear deal and judicial reform. Itâs just the way Mr. Biden works.