A Contemporary Tradition

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

Although the traditional and the contemporary are often at odds in today’s classical music world, Robert Spano will offer a compromise when he brings his Atlanta Symphony Orchestra to Carnegie Hall on Saturday evening: a tradition of presenting the contemporary.

The work in question is the New York premiere of the Here and Now by Christopher Theofanidis. Mr. Theofanidis teaches at the Peabody Conservatory of Music in Baltimore and was recently composer of the year for the Pittsburgh Symphony. Commissioned by Mr. Spano himself, the Here and Now is a song cycle for chorus and orchestra based on the poetry of the 13th-century Sufi sage Jelaluddin Rumi, who spent 10 years searching for his master, a wandering dervish known as Shams of Tabriz. Rumi developed the habit of turning in place while meditating, giving birth to the whirling dervish tradition.

While the work is an unusual composition, it is not surprising that the Atlanta Symphony is its vehicle; the symphony has been a leader in the introduction of contemporary works. When Robert Shaw took over the ensemble in the 1960s, he did much more than simply elevate its musical standards. Shaw was renowned for his work with the world’s choruses, and an annual choral event at Carnegie Hall still bears his name. Mr. Theofanidis, in fact, waxes emotional when mentioning this aspect of his commission. In his family, Mr. Theofanidis said, Shaw was a hero. Working with the Atlanta Symphony chorus feels “like my grandfather smiling down on me.” Shaw was a tireless champion of the modern. He programmed Penderecki, Schoenberg, Lutoslawski, Ligeti, and Schuller, and also commissioned a work by Ulysses Kay, significantly for that time and place, a black composer. After his board complained, Shaw scheduled 10 uncompromising works by Charles Ives. The board asked for Shaw’s resignation, but public outcry saved his position.

Mr. Spano is no stranger to New York, having spent six years as music director of the Brooklyn Philharmonic. Mr. Spano’s ardent advocacy for new music has triggered a Pavlovian response from some New York critics, who exaggerate their praise of his renditions of the classics. But his championship of the contemporary cannot be gainsaid. His years in Brooklyn saw productions of operas by Thomas Ades and John Adams, and world premieres by Bright Sheng, Philip Glass, Michael Hersch, and Mr. Theofanidis.

As for Mr. Theofanidis, the composer has said that this music reminds him of “Walt Whitman in the now.” It does indeed reflect the Sufi sense of time, what cosmological scholar Dr. Arife Ellen Hammerle explains as “the intersection between the universe and the human being in a timeless dimension of space.”

The 13 inventive songs range from a cappella chorus at the cycle’s opening, to chorus and orchestra, to an epigrammatic soloist, and finally to one Technicolor duet. In the fourth song, “All day and night, music,” the chorus erupts into a multifaceted pealing of campanilian voices, individual bells tolling in the rarefied air. Throughout the choral writing, there is clarity of line that allows for complex constructions to sound layered but not soupy. Mr. Theofanidis is especially adept at separating voices intelligently.

Song no. 7, “The one who pours is wilder than we,” is a jazzy interlude. No. 9, “Drumsound rises,” is reminiscent of ancient music — or, at least, reflects modern man’s fantasy of how music must have sounded in the days of Christ.

The soloist is a baritone, and, for this concert, Mr. Spano has enlisted the services of one of the fastest rising stars in the operatic firmament, Nathan Gunn. Mr. Gunn’s numbers serve as philosophical signposts for an otherwise decidedly non-euclidian journey.

Mr. Theofanidis resists the temptation to go Middle Eastern until the penultimate song, “The urgency of love,” for soprano, tenor, chorus, and orchestra. For this New York premiere, Mr. Spano will employ Hila Plitmann and Richard Clement, both of whom appear on his CD of the work.

Also on the program is the complete Daphnis et Chloé of Maurice Ravel. While even the best ballet score can have some dead spots when presented in the concert hall without the excitement and beauty provided by the dancers, Ravel conceived of this work as a symphony, with chorus first and a score for the dance second. A kaleidoscopic essay in orchestral color and shifting textures, a good performance can leave the listener breathless and unaware that the work lasts for an entire hour. On Saturday night, all that will matter will be the There and Then.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use