Heroes and Villains Merge on the Streets

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

Though it is too heavily freighted with sentimentality and a clunky political subtext, “Princesas,” by Fernando León de Aranoa, is a frequently interesting portrait of the friendship between two prostitutes in Madrid.

Caye (Candela Peña) is one of several working girls who hang out at the beauty parlor run by Gloria (Llum Barrera) and grumble as they look out on the adjacent square where immigrant women are, as they see it, stealing work from them by undercutting their prices.

When Caye arrives 10 minutes late for an appointment with a john, she discovers that one of the immigrants, a beautiful Dominican named Zulema (Micaela Nevárez), has beaten her to him. She tells off the interloper, but later realizes that she is her neighbor.

One day, when Caye hears the television turned up too loud in Zulema’s apartment and finds the door ajar, she goes in to find her beaten up by a man she has been sleeping with in return for promises of legalizing her status. Caye takes her to the hospital, and the two become close friends.

The political lesson in having a would-be Spanish nativist like Caye pal up with an immigrant is mostly understated and unobtrusive. The only breach in their relationship comes when Caye sends the spaced-out Blanca (María Ballesteros), also known as “Miss Methadone,” to warn Zulema of an impending bust because she’s afraid of revealing their friendship to the other girls at Gloria’s. But even this is soon overcome.

Of much more interest to Mr. Aranoa is getting the most he can out of the well-worn theme of the pathos in the life of a prostitute. The pun on Caye’s name — a homophone of the Spanish word for “street”— is repeated in order to remind us of her emblematic status as poster girl for the heartbreak of whoredom.

Zulema has left her small son with her mother back in the Dominican Republic and sends home all she can from her earnings in Spain. At least, says Caye, she has something happy to look back on. “I don’t feel nostalgic,” she says, since “nothing worth missing has ever happened to me. How can you be nostalgic for something that hasn’t happened yet?”

She hangs on to that “yet” through most of the picture as a fragile lifeline of hope. Caye dreams of one day being picked up from work — “That’s what love is,” she imagines, never having experienced it before — and for a time she thinks her dream has come true in the form of a shy computer engineer called Manuel (Luis Callejo).

In fact, the dream does come true, but only because she dares not hope for much. “I would like to be the woman of his life,” she confides in Zulema, “even if just for one day.”

Their courtship consists of little more than a single scene, in which Caye goes out to dinner with Manuel and tries to tell him how she feels, which she only knows how to do in sexual terms. In the middle of the meal, she has to leave the table to perform a sex act on a former client who might otherwise make her identity known.

To Manuel, Caye has half-jokingly suggested that she has a secret identity, like a superhero. When she returns to the table, he says to her: “I know everything. You didn’t go to the bathroom.” As a panicked look fills her eyes, he smiles. “You went to save the world. You stopped a train from derailing.You saved everyone and came back. Am I right?”

The idea of the superhero (or superheroine, as Caye insists) is meant to be cognate with that of the “princesses” from which the film takes its title and which she and Zulema like to imagine they are. And in a way they are saving people, Mr. Aranoa almost wants to say, though they are reviled instead of loved for it.

It’s one of several points at which the director pushes the pathos too far, and the film teeters on the brink of emotional excess. A more astringent touch is added by Caye’s middle-class family dinners with her mother, brother, and sister-in-law, which punctuate the film and at which she looks much more miserable than at any time in her life as a prostitute. (About that life, the family naturally knows nothing.)

Her mother (Mariana Cordero) is a dour woman who, Caye believes, sends flowers to herself in order to make people think she has an admirer, or that her husband, who abandoned her long ago, is trying to apologize and make up.

Caye insists that her father died three years ago, but her mother refuses to believe it. On the one occasion when Zulema joins her at the family table and Caye explains that her mother prints the cards that come with the flowers so no one will know she has sent them to herself, Zulema asks: “What do the cards say?”

Caye looks blank. No one has ever bothered to read them.The hostility between Caye and her mother runs so deep that she can’t recognize her mother’s loneliness as the mirror image of her own. The leitmotif of the cell-phone ring-tone that Caye can’t answer in her mother’s presence comes to stand for the isolation in which they stand with respect to each other.

All this is very persuasively sketched and helps make Mr. Aranoa’s film a mostly enjoyable and moving one that is, like him, just a little too much in love with its own superheroines.

jbowman@nysun.com


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use