I Think We Have a Winner

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

In all the Bush-bashing or Kerry-promoting movies that I have seen during this election season – ever wonder whose side Hollywood is on? – I hadn’t until now seen one that I thought might sway the election.


Michael Moore’s “Fahrenheit 9/11” is great propaganda, but only if you come to it (as so many do) already persuaded that your president is a really bad and/or stupid guy. The slightly more disguised messages of “The Day After Tomorrow” or “The Manchurian Candidate” or “Silver City” can’t emerge effectively, it seems to me, from three such artistic disasters. And the straightforward left-wing agitprop won’t be seen by more than a handful of true believers.


But in George Butler’s “Going Upriver: The Long War of John Kerry,” I think we have a winner. This paean to the Democratic standard-bearer as a Lincolnesque figure, a war hero, and also a hero of the (Vietnam) anti-war movement, actually might change some minds – those of wavering Kerry supporters who may well be persuaded by it to vote for President Bush.


Senator Kerry’s obsession with Vietnam has always been curious. At the Democratic convention he tried to make his service in Vietnam his chief qualification for the presidency. But “Going Upriver” shows that it is not really the short war – the four months he spent in Vietnam before his third purple heart allowed him to go home – that he is proud of but the “long war” which began with his assumption of the leadership of the Vietnam Veterans Against the War and has continued ever since. This he regards as the truest expression of his patriotism.


I think a majority of Americans will disagree. He does, too, or he would not have taken the trouble to create that misleading impression at the convention.


The movie lets the cat out of the bag. It begins with an anonymous voiceover telling us that we can’t understand John Kerry at all without understanding what Vietnam means to him. It is the central episode in his life. He has throughout his political career applied what he believes to be the “lessons” he learned from his short period in-country.


Whatever else this may mean, it certainly seems to mean that he measures all American foreign-policy initiatives, including the war against Islamic terrorism, by the yardstick of Vietnam – at least the anti-war movement’s version of Vietnam.


Thus, George Bush fills the Nixon role as Tricky George, deceiving the country into the “quagmire” of Iraq, the new Vietnam, which is “the wrong war at the wrong time in the wrong place.” That’s why Mr. Kerry says that the President “owes the American people the truth and he owes the troops the truth” – as if he took it for grant ed that Bush were another Johnson or Nixon, routinely lying about the war.


The real “lessons” Mr. Kerry learned were not from Vietnam but from the self-conceit of his fellow anti-warriors as noble victims awakening the conscience of their country to the immorality of a war waged by not one but two American administrations filled with wicked, corrupt, and unprincipled men – or at best men in thrall to what Neil Sheehan, one of those interviewed for the movie, contemptuously calls “Cold War myths.”


Ironic, isn’t it, that this view of the war has now itself become a myth? It is a myth lovingly tended by the media – who are still proud of what they see, rightly, as their own key role in getting America out of Vietnam – and by the “progressive” or Carterite political tendency in foreign policy, to which Kerry has belonged throughout his career.


Neither Mr. Kerry nor Mr. Butler seems to realize that the great majority of the American people do not subscribe to this tendency. Nor, although they have come in retrospect to think of the Vietnam war as a mistake, have they ever bought the protestors’ line that their elected leaders were evil men. It will come as a bit of a jolt to those who don’t remember the passions of the time to see an ex-Marine in the film throw his medals onto the steps of the capital while calling both Presidents Johnson and Nixon “murderers.”


Did Mr. Kerry think that, too? He threw – or pretended to throw – his medals away, though the movie omits this detail. He also said that his fellow soldiers had routinely committed atrocities, and that the war was “immoral”, “obscene,” and “insane.” This was the language of those who supposed, in the common formulation of the times, that America was “a sick society.”


I think Mr. Kerry himself was hinting as much in his now famous testimony before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, the climax of the film, when he said that he hoped we would look back on the war and the successful protests against it as a time “when America turned.”


But, looking back, we can’t help noticing that America never really did “turn,” at least not in the way that he meant it. And the way it did turn after the protests – towards individualism, permissiveness, and less social cohesion – is something we still have decidedly mixed feelings about.


Mr. Butler’s attempt to associate Mr. Kerry with what remains, in the eyes of a significant minority, the romance of the protests is only likely to suggest to the majority how shrill and hysterical those protests were. The aging anti-warriors may now remember the hippie garb and grooming, the self-righteous sloganeering, Bella Abzug and Coretta Scott King and Peter Paul and Mary singing “Blowing in the Wind” with nothing but affection. But to most people today, it all seems just a bit silly.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use