Shannon McArdle Speaks for Herself

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

Some artists hide behind the scrim of creative license, contending that even the bloodiest confessions are merely the fabric of fictional conceit. Names are changed to protect the guilty. Catastrophic experiences are related by imaginary characters. And everything else is coincidental. Bob Dylan, in his 2004 memoir, implied that his 1974 classic, “Blood on the Tracks,” widely assumed to be about his divorce, was in fact based on Chekhov.

It took less than half a pint of Belgian wheat beer to get the skinny from Shannon McArdle. The Brooklyn singer-songwriter had no qualms when she admitted that the tortured tales on her debut solo album, “Summer of the Whore” (Bar/None), are explicitly inspired by the unexpected collapse of her marriage during the winter of 2007. One day her husband of two years, Tim Bracy, with whom she had performed since 2000 as a member of the indie-rock outfit the Mendoza Line, up and left. To add injury to insult, Ms. McArdle tripped on her way into a subway one day, took a plunge down the stairs, and was rushed to an emergency room.

“I had a lump on my back the size of a watermelon,” she said.

Luckily, it was only two herniated discs, not a broken back. But what could more aptly symbolize the feeling of “hitting bottom” than actually hitting bottom?

Recording “Summer of the Whore,” which is released today and will be celebrated in Ms. McArdle’s performance tonight at the Mercury Lounge, became a process of emotional exorcism and redemption — and, despite its provocative title, less an anthem to abandon than a rueful reminiscence. The idea came when Ms. McArdle, 31, and former Mendoza Line drummer Adam Gold, likewise newly single, began collaborating on tracks she had quickly written in the wake of the breakup. Afternoon meetings over margaritas would find “one if not both of us looking pretty rough,” Ms. McArdle said. “Adam came up with it first. He’d ask, ‘Were you a whore last night?'”

Ms. McArdle, a native of Albany, Ga., who fell in with the Mendoza Line while attending the University of Georgia in the late 1990s, had a definitively Southern lilt to her voice when we spoke, and sat with a certain poise that would befit a schoolteacher. As it turned out, she works two jobs as an instructor of English as a second language. But the racy album title isn’t entirely a joke.

“It makes sense when you listen to it,” she said. “It’s not derogatory or in-your-face. I was doing everything out of desperation, trying to feel somewhat secure and somewhat confident, somewhat content and somewhat preoccupied. I think it’s quite appropriate.”

Stylistically, the album’s succinct song cycle rarely veers into nail-spitting Lucinda Williams territory, even though Ms. McArdle shares an affinity for country-rock textures and literary constructions. The melancholy undertow of the opener, “Poison My Cup,” could belong to an early-’70s radio ballad. Meanwhile, the tasteful percussive accents, muted twang, and breathy upper-register choral notes of “Paint the Walls,” which is the album’s most direct song about suddenly living alone, could easily serve a jazz singer.

“The record is not supposed to be nasty or even insulting,” Ms. McArdle said, talking over some vintage punk rock on the jukebox at the Commonwealth bar in Park Slope. “Although there are moments of that, I just wanted to make a record and this was the only thing I could conjure up.”

Nonetheless, like such kindred spirits as Neko Case, Kelly Hogan, and the Handsome Family, Ms. McArdle reached back into the mountain-ballad tradition to find a relevant parable to convey her personal experiences. “That Night in June,” beyond the shimmer of its slow-waltz tempo and Ms. McArdle’s dreamy vocals, is laced with horror.

“It’s about a woman who was drowned by her true love,” she said. “This man drowns his bride and goes on this journey of self-loathing, but it turns out he has no conscience and he’s just a murderer. The woman dies, but there’s a rebirth of all these incarnations of the woman.”

If the process was meant to be therapeutic, it certainly worked. Ms. McArdle, whose neighbors in Prospect Heights sometimes call her “Snowflake,” seems to have her groove back. Even her ESL students, many of whom are Mexican and African, have taken notice when the occasional interview appears. Although, as might be expected, some things are lost in translation.

“They’ll come in, saying, ‘Teacher you didn’t tell me … What is ‘Summer of the Whore’?”

Ms. McArdle performs tonight at the Mercury Lounge (217 E. Houston St. at Avenue A, 212-260-4700).


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use