Shopping Early in the Morning To Feed City During the Day

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

“See that brown spot? Whole Foods would never accept that,” said Scott Stark.


Mr. Stark bought the apple anyway, the entire case in fact, because he knows his customers. He knows that his other extremely persnickety customer, the upscale Four Seasons restaurant, will accept that apple and its neighbors in the crate at the Hunts Point market.


Why?


“Well, it is an extremely good apple. But Four Seasons is going to cut it up and put it into a pie, and Whole Foods is going to display it,” Mr. Star said at exactly 4:17 a.m. in a very cold shed in the Bronx.


“In fact, there is absolutely nothing wrong with that brown spot. The apple will be fine. It’s just that people are particular,” he said.


Mr. Stark loves particular people, especially if they are buyers for persnickety chefs and upscale produce departments. That’s how he makes his living.


Mr. Stark puts his highly trained but only 26-year-old fingers on almost every piece of produce he buys at Hunt’s Point (at hours when “it is tough to find girls”) for his exacting customers, which also include the Post House and Mitchel London Foods.


“Chefs like us, “Mr. Stark said of himself and his partner, Mark Bastidas, “because we actually look at the stuff, as opposed to some guy getting paid $8 an hour just to load it.”


An overnight with Messrs. Stark and Bastidas at the Hunts Point market is educational: Look for liquid at the bottom of the raspberry box; rattle the green peppers – you should hear nothing; asparagus tips must be firm, their stalks green not brownish; talk to the wholesalers’ unloaders – they know what came in last and what is freshest, and maybe it’s not the same thing, and of course, touch everything.


Mr. Stark gets even closer to the earth in the growing seasons, as he deals directly with what he calls “my farmers,” mostly near the city, but sometimes he travels as far away as a field just shy of the Delaware Memorial Bridge, where he says the corn is particularly sweet.


Mr. Stark, a restaurant management graduate of the University of Massachusetts, fell into his present job through two serendipitous events. A little more than three years ago, he was working for a company that connected local farms directly to markets and restaurants in Manhattan, when it suddenly closed without warning.


“I was told on a Friday that it was to close on the Monday,” he said. “We started this business over a weekend.”


He struggled to keep his customers for the farmers. In the first week he did about $800 in business out of the back of a borrowed Pathfinder – compared to about $18,000 to $20,000 he does a week this month, which he said was his dead slowest period. His best day was clearing a $4,000 profit – not counting the mortgage on his two trucks and other normal business expenses.


And the other bit of luck he had was he interned for two summers at the Four Seasons, developing friendships there, from which came one of his first and biggest clients.


That’s how he got his clients. How he keeps them can be seen in a single hustle through Hunts Point.


Mr. Stark’s company, of course, makes its money in the difference between what he pays at Hunts Point (in the winter) and what he sells his fancy friends. Time after time, he rejected offers from his new friends in the Bronx for discounts on crates of fruits and vegetables when the spread between the two costs would have made him quite a bit of change.


“You see these Romaines? He’s offered me a very good price on them,” Mr. Stark said, “but you also see these brown spots. I’d rather make a buck less and keep my customers happy.”


He would like to expand, he said, and perhaps buy another truck.


“But we’d hire only drivers,” he said. “Mark and I would still choose the goods. We’d be up here. They’d still see our pretty faces.”


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use