How To Handle Getting Stumped During Job Interviews

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

University of Pennsylvania senior Ariel Horn was interviewing for an entry-level spot with a New York management consulting firm in April 2002 when a curveball “brain-teaser” intended to test her analytical ability caught her off guard.


“How many haircutters are there in the U.S.?” the interviewer asked. Trying to craft a logical reply, Ms. Horn became bogged down in irrelevant details and gave a far-fetched estimate of 50 million. “I felt like I was the dumbest person he had interviewed,” she says. She didn’t get the job – and never found out the number of haircutters.


Everyone gets stumped at times during interviews. Whether you flub a trick question, arrive inadequately prepared, or become tongue-tied about something obvious, how you handle such nerve-racking situations may determine if you are shown the door or your new office.


Here are common reasons that job hunters become flummoxed by interview queries and what you can do to recover:


Insufficient homework about a potential employer.


A senior executive recently bragged to recruiter Gerard Roche about being such a big gun in the computer industry that he knew the top brass at IBM. “So you must know Palmisano,” Mr. Roche said, alluding to Samuel Palmisano, IBM’s leader.


The job candidate responded, “Oh, I know Paul very well,” the Heidrick & Struggles International senior chairman remembers. “As soon as somebody does something like that, I open the trap door and they’re never heard from again.”


It’s far better to admit that you don’t know an answer than to guess wrong. For example, a 22-year-old college graduate failed to research the Fraternal Order of Police in advance of her April 2003 interview for an administrative assistant’s post, first scouring its newsletter just moments before being ushered into the president’s office. He asked her to describe the union’s size. “I had no clue,” she recollects. “I admitted I didn’t read up enough beforehand.”


Impressed by her candor, the union offered her employment.


Inadequate preparation of your pitch.


Rehearsing your best selling points may not suffice, especially when you’re thrown a thorny question designed to assess your expertise. A typical example: “How would you solve our marketing challenge in China?” Request time to reflect rather than spewing a torrent of ill-conceived remarks.


A prospective labor-relations manager ably fielded a negotiating-strategy question during his Armstrong World Industries interview. But he ducked a subsequent one about the negotiations’ outcome. He said he needed to check his records and then responded within a day.


“His quick follow-up cemented the deal,” says Matt Angello, senior vice president of human resources at the Lancaster, Pa., maker of floor covering, ceilings, and cabinets.


A belated realization that you misunderstood a question.


In his memoir “Kitchen Confidential,” New York chef Anthony Bourdain describes how he was once close to clinching a Park Avenue steakhouse job when the owner, a Scotsman with a thick brogue, asked: “What do you know about me?”


“It really threw me [because] I had answered every other question perfectly,” Mr. Bourdain recalls. But he hadn’t heard of the owner before, so he replied, “Next to nothing!”


The chef was politely escorted to the door and was halfway down the block before he realized he had misheard. The Scotsman had actually asked, “What do you know about meat?”


Mr. Bourdain felt he couldn’t go back and correct himself because he had lost his momentum.


But you may be able to recover from a similar situation. Repeat a perplexing question out loud and then ask the interviewer, “Do I have this right?” suggests John Kador, author of the book, “How to Ace the Brainteaser Interview.”


Far-fetched questions that seem irrelevant.


In September, a sales vice president of an apparel maker was supposed to interview Vivian Adams about becoming a national-account business manager who could introduce the company’s T-shirts and other casual clothing to military retail outlets.


But the vice president called in sick. Instead, Ms. Adams met officials from a different division, which procured fabric for worker uniforms. “They knew nothing about what I was talking about,” Ms. Adams says. One executive asked her an irrelevant question about uniforms used by Veterans Hospital cafeteria staffers.


“I said, ‘I have no idea what they wear,'” Ms. Adams recalls. Deftly, she steered the conversation back to her presentation about huge potential sales from military outlets.


On the other hand, being stumped by an interviewer may mean “that’s not the right job for you,” says Ms. Horn, the consultancy applicant who flubbed the haircutter question. Now teaching English in New York, she transformed the travails of her job search into a book titled “Help Wanted, Desperately.”


The autobiographical novel appeared this fall.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use