The Chirac Tax
This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

Jacques Chirac’s latest stunt, an effort to combat African disease by piling another tax on air travelers, is classic Chirac. Starting in 2006, he wants to tack on a fee to the cost of airline tickets to and from France. The charge would be funneled into a fund to tackle diseases such as AIDS and tuberculosis in Africa. French officials call it a “solidarity levy.” Mr. Chirac wants to expand the tax worldwide, raising $12 billion a year.
It’s not at all clear that more money will help fight disease in the developing world. Consider but one way current aid money is spent: to pay taxes imposed on medicines by the developing countries themselves. As an American Enterprise Institute scholar, Roger Bate, has noted, Kenya imposes taxes and tariffs of 38% on many drugs, Nigeria 28%, and Uganda 31%.
Without addressing this problem, Mr. Chirac’s plan will merely subsidize governments that are essentially profiteering from foreign aid. A better start might be a step in favor of free trade. But for Mr. Chirac, “solidarity” apparently extends only as far as a marginal surcharge on airline tickets purchased mainly by people from other countries.