Bitters Buyer’s Guide

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

Looking to explore the world of cocktail bitters? These brands, which range in price from $2 to $8 a bottle, are available at LeNell’s (416 Van Brunt St., between Coffey and Van Dyke streets, Brooklyn, 718-360-0838), and elsewhere as noted.


ANGOSTURA AROMATIC BITTERS (also available at many supermarkets): Classic bitters brand, and deservedly so, with a complex mix of spice notes. “It’s very good for Manhattans or Old Fashioneds,” cocktail historian David Wondrich said. “And it’s excellent with rum, like in a Mojito – not traditional, necessarily, but it works.”


PEYCHAUD’S AROMATIC COCKTAIL BITTERS (also availble from buffalotrace.com): The classic New Orleans bitters, a crucial ingredient to a Sazerac, and the only brand aside from Angostura to survive from pre-Prohibition days. “It’s very distinct from Angostura,” Mr. Wondrich said. “More anise, black cherry, things like that. It blends very well with brandy, or any cocktail using cognac.”


FEE’S OLD FASHION AROMATIC BITTERS: “More of a Christmas spice flavor than Angostura, a little less complex,” Mr. Wondrich said. “But it’s great with old-fashioned whiskey cocktails.”


FEE’S WEST INDIAN ORANGE BITTERS: A classic orange bitters. Fruity and not too spicy, it’s ideal for a martini.


REGANS’ ORANGE BITTERS NO. 6 (also available at buffalotrace.com): Developed last year by cocktail maven Gary Regan, this orange elixir is less orange-y, more complex, and spicier than Fee’s orange product, with lots of cinnamon and clove notes.


STIRRINGS BLOOD ORANGE BITTERS (also available at stirrings.com): Unlike all the other bitters on this list, this new product has no alcohol, and is therefore more like a juice, or even a punch, than a classic bitters concoction. Very interesting flavor profile, though – lots of potential here.


FEE’S PEACH BITTERS: Pleasantly fruity and extremely aromatic, this product was developed by Fee’s about 15 years ago at the urging of Ted “Dr. Cocktail” Haigh, a mixology enthusiast who’s been on a long crusade to revive bitters culture. “I haven’t found much use for it,” Mr. Wondrich said, “but there are some nice Art Deco drinks that call for it.”


FEE’S MINT BITTERS: Disturbingly similar to Scope – use real mint in your cocktails instead.


UNDERBERG BITTERS: Packaged in a tiny, beautiful 20ml bottle (about two-thirds of an ounce), the full contents are meant to be poured into a bitters glass and consumed in one gulp, as a digestif. But according to the LeNell’s proprietress, LeNell Smothers, it also can be used in cocktails. “It’s such a nice little size, you can slip it into your purse, take it with you to dinner, and take a nip of bitters,” she said.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use