Commander: British Forces Almost Abandoned Afghanistan

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

British forces in southern Afghanistan came within hours of retreating from a key base because they suffered a critical shortage of helicopters, the task force commander has disclosed.

In an exclusive interview with the Daily Telegraph, Brigadier Ed Butler said Taliban fire was so heavy and accurate at Musa Qala, a key forward base in northern Helmand, that army helicopters faced a serious risk of being hit.

He said the loss of such crucial equipment — together with the political impact of a large loss of life — meant that he came close to ordering his soldiers to abandon the base.

Brigadier Butler said he had warned his superiors early last month that the intensity of Taliban attacks was such that mounting air supply and casualty evacuation missions was likely to lead to the loss of Chinook helicopters.

The brigadier, who leaves his posting at the end of the week, said: “The strategic significance of losing Musa Qala would have been huge, but that was set against the likelihood of helicopters being lost.The political impact, particularly so soon after the loss of the Nimrod, was also going to be huge.”

A Nimrod was lost with 14 crewmen, apparently because of technical failure, over southern Afghanistan on September 4.There are only six British Chinooks in theater, with two more on their way, and commanders have made repeated pleas to NATO allies to send additional aircraft.

“We were not going to be beaten by the Taliban in Musa Qala,” Brigadier Butler said, “but the threat to helicopters from very professional Taliban fighters and particularly mortar crews was becoming unacceptable. We couldn’t guarantee that we weren’t going to lose helicopters.”

The paratroopers were within 36 hours of abandoning the base before tribal elders approached the Afghan government to negotiate a cease-fire between British forces and the Taliban in the area.

“I told them: ‘You tell the Taliban to stop firing at us, and my soldiers will stop firing back at you,'” the brigadier said.He called the cease-fire, which has held for 16 days, an: “Afghan solution.” “We are bidding for people’s minds here. The people here are sick of war, and they are turning to the Afghan government to end it.

“I am pragmatic about this.We won’t

turn Afghanistan around overnight as some people continue to believe. Moral, legal, and ethical compasses of some people may be tested by this process, but the repercussions of failure are too great to be contemplated.”

Brigadier Butler defended the decision to commit forces to “platoon houses,” isolated bases in the north of Helmand, which tied down almost half the available British infantry and became the focus of continuous Taliban attacks.

“We didn’t plan to occupy the platoon houses, President Karzai and Governor Daoud wanted British forces to hold north Helmand,” he said.”But the unintended consequence of going into the platoon houses is that we have defeated the Taliban for this year, tactically, in north Helmand, and from this an opportunity has emerged.”

Following the Musa Qala cease-fire, there has been a reduction in violence. Brigadier Butler said tribal elders from other districts were also negotiating with the provincial government to establish similar deals.

Addressing the men of 3rd Battalion, the Parachute Regiment, yesterday afternoon as they prepared to leave Afghanistan, Brigadier Butler said: “What is important is that this was a battle of attrition, and the Taliban blinked before we did.

“They capitulated, they made the fatal error of thinking that the Parachute Regiment would cut and run.”

But he acknowledged that other factors may be at play. The new poppy planting season began two weeks ago, which requires high levels of agricultural labor, men who might otherwise be fighting.

The Taliban and the opium economy rely heavily on hired labor from the mass of unemployed in the South.

Fighting is also a largely seasonal activity that drops away as winter approaches, when the Taliban retreat to regroup and rearm.

“I fully acknowledge that we could be being duped; that the Taliban may be buying time to reconstitute and regenerate,” Brigadier Butler said.

“But every day that there is no fighting, the power moves to the hands of the tribal elders who are turning to the government of Afghanistan for security and development.

“That is the glimmer of an opportunity which could be deliverable if we seize it. It is about people power, and it could gain momentum.”

He said troops would now press ahead with redevelopment work that was the focus for the original British plan.

The New York Sun

© 2023 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use