Pope Eyes Purge of Modern Music From Vatican
This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

ROME — Pope Benedict is considering a dramatic overhaul of the Vatican in order to force a return to traditional sacred music.
After reintroducing the Latin Tridentine Mass, the pope wants to widen the use of Gregorian chant and baroque sacred music. In an address to the bishops and priests of St. Peter’s Basilica last month, he said there needed to be “continuity with tradition” in their prayers and music. He referred pointedly to “the time of St. Gregory the Great,” the pope who gave his name to Gregorian chant. Gregorian chant has been reinstituted as the primary form of singing by the new choir director of St. Peter’s, Father Pierre Paul. He has also broken with the tradition set up by John Paul II of having a rotating choir, drawn from churches all over the world, to sing Mass in St. Peter’s.
The pope has recently replaced the director of pontifical liturgical celebrations, Archbishop Piero Marini, with a man closer to his heart, Monsignor Guido Marini. It is now thought he may replace the head of the Sistine Chapel choir, Giuseppe Liberto.
The International Church Music Review recently criticized the choir, saying: “The singers wanted to overshout each other, they were frequently out of tune, the sound uneven, the conducting without any artistic power, the organ and organ playing like in a second-rank country parish church.”
Monsignor Valentin Miserachs Grau, the director of the Pontifical Institute of Sacred Music, which trains church musicians, said there had been serious “deviations” in the performance of sacred music.
“How far we are from the true spirit of sacred music. How can we stand it that such a wave of inconsistent, arrogant, and ridiculous profanities have so easily gained a stamp of approval in our celebrations?” he said. He added that a pontifical office could correct the abuses, and would be “opportune.” He said: “Due to general ignorance, especially in sectors of the clergy, there exists music which is devoid of sanctity, true art, and universality.”
Monsignor Grau said that Gregorian chant was the “cardinal point” of liturgical music and that traditional music “should become again the living soul of the assembly.”
The pope favored the idea of a watchdog for church music when he was the cardinal in charge of safeguarding Catholic doctrine. He is known to be a strong supporter of Monsignor Grau, who is also in charge of the Cappella Liberiana of the Basilica of Santa Maria Maggiore in Rome.