Rice Downplays North Korean ‘Violin Diplomacy’
This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

SEOUL — On the eve of a landmark performance in Pyongyang by the New York Philharmonic, the Secretary of State Rice was next door in Seoul today lauding South Korea’s president, Lee Myung-bak, and his intent to hold North Korea to its pledge to abandon nuclear weapons.
With attention focused on the orchestra, Ms. Rice pointedly ignored the unprecedented event that some have dubbed “violin diplomacy,” and instead went out of her way twice to compliment Lee on his choice of the “Ode to Joy” from Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony to end his swearing-in ceremony.
In two brief encounters before reporters, the classically trained pianist first hailed “the universal strains of Beethoven performed so beautifully” by South Korean musicians and a choir and then told Mr. Lee himself the selection was “beautiful.”
By contrast, Ms. Rice last week said she was pleased the Philharmonic would be playing a work by the Czech composer, Antonin Dvorak, in Pyongyang, but dismissed the concert, saying: “I don’t think we should get carried away with what listening to Dvorak is going to do in North Korea.”
In Seoul, Ms. Rice also noted America and South Korea share deep “strategic interests” and “common values” like democracy and praised Mr. Lee’s inaugural address in which he promised to “strengthen our strategic alliance with the United States” and demanded openness from the North.
In his speech, Mr. Lee told South Koreans, and by extension Koreans in the North, that only “once North Korea abandons its nuclear program and chooses the path to openness” can people expect to see “a new horizon in inter-Korean cooperation.”
Ms. Rice declined to answer questions about her private discussions with Mr. Lee and the incoming South Korean foreign minister, Yu Myung-hwan, but senior officials from both sides said that what she heard was, well, music to her ears.
“We welcome this,” the assistant secretary of state for east Asian and pacific affairs, Christopher Hill, said, referring to Mr. Lee’s plan to put a more critical eye on Seoul’s policy of detente with the North than his two immediate predecessors.
They were accused of showering unconditional aid and concessions on North Korea as part of reconciliation efforts while getting little in return, something that had vexed Washington.
“President Lee said he would do all he could to strengthen (American-South Korean) cooperation in the six-party process,” Mr. Hill told reporters.
He referred to the group of six nations — America, South Korea, China, Japan, Russia, and North Korea — trying to negotiate an end to Pyongyang’s nuclear weapons development.
Meanwhile, a South Korean presidential spokesman said Mr. Lee had told Ms. Rice that he “will make the denuclearization a top principle” of his administration.
The disarmament process made major progress in the past year after Pyongyang shut down its main nuclear reactor and began disabling key atomic facilities.
The talks, however, have been deadlocked for months over whether the North has fulfilled its commitment to account for all of its nuclear programs as it committed to do in the six-party talks by December 31, 2007, a deadline that passed nearly two months ago.
The North says it has already provided the declaration, but Washington says Pyongyang has not yet given a complete accounting, particularly about alleged transfers of nuclear equipment and know-how to other countries.
Ms. Rice is in South Korea on the first leg of a three-nation Asia tour that takes her to China tomorrow and Japan on Wednesday for talks that will be dominated by the North Korea issue.
But while Ms. Rice will be seeing the key players in the process from China, Japan, and South Korea on her trip, before she left Washington she ruled out any talks with North Korean officials, saying such a meeting was neither warranted nor could be of any use in the current circumstances.
“We need a complete declaration from the North Koreans,” she said on Friday. “North Korea is quite aware of what it needs to do.”
