Turkey’s Ruling Party Narrowly Avoids Being Banned

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

ISTANBUL, Turkey — Turkey’s top court today narrowly decided against banning the ruling party over accusations that it was steering the country toward Islamic rule, preserving a government locked in a power struggle with the secular elite.

The Constitutional Court, however, delivered a strong — though unspecified — warning to the ruling Justice and Development Party and said it would lose half of its funding from the state treasury.

“The decision that came out was a warning to this party. It is a serious warning,” the court chairman, Hasim Kilic, said. “I hope that this outcome will be assessed and that the necessary measures will be taken.”

He said six of the 11 judges wanted to ban the party of the prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan. A total of seven votes were needed to ban it under court regulations.

The decision represented a reprieve for Mr. Erdogan and his allies in an overwhelmingly Muslim country with a secular system that seeks to join the European Union. A decision to ban the party would have triggered a sharp escalation in political turmoil in the NATO member, where a bomb attack on Sunday killed 17 people in Istanbul.

A ban would have severely damaged Turkey’s image as a democracy because the ruling party won a strong majority in elections last year; EU leaders have said the ruling party’s viability should be decided in elections, not courtrooms.

The court case was the latest battleground between the pious Muslims who run the government but embrace aspects of Western political and economic systems, and the secular establishment that draws support from the military and judiciary. The rift has evolved over the last century since national founder Mustafa Kemal Ataturk jettisoned Islam as a guiding force in society and politics, instead imposing a strictly secular system amid the ruins of the Ottoman Empire.

In announcing the court decision, Mr. Kilic said judges were uncomfortable handling the court case and said it exposed the need for legal reforms that will elevate the quality of Turkish democracy. European leaders had expressed alarm at the case against Turkey’s ruling party, saying its fate should be decided in an election rather than a courtroom.

“We are facing serious difficulties with regard to democracy when we deal with closure cases,” Mr. Kilic said. “But unfortunately, legal and constitutional reforms necessary to meet standards of modern democracies are not made.”

Mr. Kilic also appealed for Turkey’s political leaders to seek consensus and reduce tension.

The deputy chairman of the main opposition party, Mustafa Ozyurek, said he respected the court’s decision but noted that a majority of the judges had effectively agreed that the ruling party was a focal point for anti-secular activities.

If the ruling party “draws a lesson from this decision, then there will be no problem,” Mr. Ozyurek, of the Republican People’s Party, said. “But if it does not, then Turkey will be dragged into chaos once again.”

CNN-Turk television said the court had voted 10-1 to deprive the ruling party of state aid. The party stands to lose an estimated $15 million from the state treasury this year.

In March, Turkey’s chief prosecutor asked the Constitutional Court to disband Mr. Erdogan’s party and bar him and 70 other party members from joining a political party for five years.

The president, Abdullah Gul, was also on the prosecutor’s list.

Prominent party leaders have backgrounds in political Islam, and the party itself is a successor to parties that were banned in the past. But those leaders now say they are not following an Islamic agenda, citing EU-backed reforms as proof.

“This party is definitely advocating a more moderate streak of thought than its predecessors,” a political science professor at Istanbul’s Bilgi University, Ilter Turan, said. Earlier, Mr. Turan said: “No matter what the decision is, this case shows that Turkey needs a restructuring of its laws and a constitutional reform.”

The judges began hearing the case Monday, a day after two bomb explosions at a packed Istanbul square. It was the deadliest attack in Turkey in almost five years. Turkish officials blamed Kurdish rebels, who denied responsibility.

The timing of the attack on the eve of the Constitutional Court’s deliberations raised speculation over a link. Prosecutors are also preparing a case against alleged coup-plotters, including retired army officers, who stand accused of trying to bring down the Islamic-oriented government by fomenting chaos in Turkey.

The conflict between the government and secular opponents escalated last year during Mr. Gul’s candidacy for the presidency, and the military issued a warning to the government that recalled past coups by the armed forces. But the Justice and Development Party triumphed by winning 47% of the votes in general elections, and 341 seats in the 550-seat Parliament.

This year, the party attempted to lift a decades-old ban on the wearing of head scarves at universities, but the top court overturned that bill, saying it was anti-secularist. The chief prosecutor, Abdurrahman Yalcinkaya, cited the head scarf bill as proof the government is trying to scrap secularist principles enshrined in the Constitution.

The court has banned two dozen political parties since it was established in 1963. But none had such strong electoral support as the current ruling party.

___

Associated Press writers C. Onur Ant in Istanbul and Suzan Fraser in Ankara contributed to this report.


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use