Woman, 75, Narrowly Escapes Being Burned Alive as Elder Abuse Grows in India

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

NEW DELHI — The funeral pyre was moments from being lit when a movement on the bier triggered panic among staff at the crematorium in southern India. Then, as they rushed to examine the elderly woman under the shroud, her three sons suddenly abandoned their “mourning” and fled.

In a shocking example of India’s growing disregard for its elderly citizens, Arti Padmati, a 75-year-old widow, narrowly escaped being cremated alive by her own children earlier this month.

Fed up with caring for her in her battle against cancer, the family had taken her to King George Hospital in the city of Vishakhapatnam, expecting her to die there.

Instead, after some days, she had been discharged while still in a stupor. Rather than taking her home, her offspring drove their mother straight to the crematorium.

“At first, they ran away when the crematorium staff got angry,” a district police officer, Jagdish Murali, said. “But later, they had second thoughts, thinking she might give their address and call us, so they came back and took her away.”

Mr. Murali was not particularly surprised. In recent years, he has seen many elderly people being dumped by their children at bus and railway stations and hospital parking lots. Once unheard of, the problem of families neglecting, fleecing, and abusing elderly parents is something that HelpAge India and other elderly advocacy groups now see every day.

“Cases of cruelty have doubled over the past decade,” said HelpAge’s chief executive, Mathew Cherian. “Children want the father’s property but not the father.”

In New Delhi alone, the charity receives 45 complaints of mistreatment a month. In India’s biggest city, Mumbai, the Dignity Foundation receives more than a dozen calls a day from distraught parents, most complaining about children who have taken their property but are unwilling to look after them. Two weeks ago, the foundation’s staff had to come to the aid of an 82-year-old widower after he had been persuaded to vacate his home and move in with his married son who promised to care for him. The son then bamboozled him into selling the empty house, saying it was no longer needed.

“Once he and his wife had pocketed the proceeds, they pretended they were going to a wedding out of town and that the father would be safer in a hotel than if he stayed alone in the house. But it was just a trick to get him out,” the president of the Dignity Foundation, Sheilu Sreenivasan, said.

Until very recently, the family and extended family systems were the bedrock of Indian society. The elderly were not viewed as a “burden” but as an integral part of the family, to be respected and cared for, a tradition that allowed many Indians to sneer at the Western practice of dumping the elderly people into care facilities.

But part of the price being paid by India for its economic boom and new affluence is the crumbling of traditional values and the extended family as an institution. Married children want to live separately in nuclear families; they lead busy lives in small city flats too cramped for both children and parents.

The number of old people is also rising, as life expectancy has doubled to 64 from 32 in the past 50 years. In 2001, India had 75 million people older the age 60. By 2016, this will rise to 112 million, or more than one in 10 of the population. In the absence of state pensions, which are available only for government employees, the vast majority will have to rely on their offspring for care in their final years.
Alarmed at the age time-bomb, the government has drafted an Old Peoples’ Care, Protection, and Maintenance Bill, making it mandatory for children to look after their parents in later life.

Due to be tabled in parliament next month, it will allow parents to take their children to court for maintenance, or face a fine or a three month jail sentence. But many doubt if legislation will suffice. “It may help those who are destitute, but few Indian parents will have the heart to take their children to court. I certainly couldn’t,” said Jagdish Jain, 75, who was evicted from his home in New Delhi by his son and daughter-in-law two years ago, after they had transferred the property into their name.

The new trends can be seen in the number of elder-care facilities in the country: up to more than 1,000 from 300 in 2002.

At Gharaunda Home, just outside New Delhi, past the sprawling farmhouses where the rich spend their weekends, Babulal and Premlata Awasthi, both in their late 70s, are resigned to dying in their windowless room.

Not one of their three sons or two daughters is in touch. They lost their home in Lajpat Nagar, New Delhi, last year when their son-in-law, who lived with them, suggested that they sell it in order to build a bigger one. He and his wife then vanished with the money. None of their other children would take them in.

“I wonder what my children tell people about us. Maybe they say we’re dead,” said Ms. Awasthi, who is a tall woman with fine features. “I never thought my children would throw me away like this.”

In their bedroom, just off the television room, Mr. Awasthi talks of how even his funeral will be odd because, in Hindu tradition, the son must light the funeral pyre. “I’ve told Premlata not to tell the children when I die. She can light my pyre,” he said. After a pause, he gestured to the staff nearby. “Or any of these people. They’ve been kinder than my own blood.”


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use