McCullough’s Miracle: Recovering the Heroic Story of 1776

One of the first things I did after signing a contract to write a biography of Samuel Adams was to try to hire a researcher who worked with David McCullough on his “John Adams.”Mike Hill, who has since emerged as an accomplished author in his own right, turned out to be helpful, a skilled researcher and an exceptionally gracious person. In retrospect, though, what my call to him was really about wasn’t so much my need for research assistance or even for guidance as a first-time book author setting off on a big project. It was about my admiration for McCullough, who died this week at age 89.The news of McCullough’s death set me to thinking about what, precisely, it was that had me so admiring of his example and eager to emulate it. Part of McCullough’s greatness was his combination of writerly craft and commercial success. A lot of the historical heavy lifting on John Adams was done by academically trained historians working at a slow pace with government and philanthropic funding on the Adams Papers project of the Massachusetts Historical Society. McCullough took what they had found, boiled it down, and rewrote it in a way that was accessible and interesting to a wide audience. “John Adams” was published in 2001 by Simon & Schuster, a commercial publisher with a profit motive. It became an HBO miniseries.McCullough’s book on the the Wright Brothers traced how the entrepreneurial pioneers of the airplane outperformed competing efforts by the government-funded Smithsonian. While building on the work of academic historians, McCullough was also filling a gap left open by them.The university professors increasingly focused on unearthing America’s flaws, its history of discrimination against women and blacks and indigenous peoples. They described a past to recoil against or to be ashamed of, not to be proud of. McCullough, derided as middlebrow, outsmarted the professors by understanding that the American Founders and the Constitution they crafted, if imperfect, were nonetheless worthy, perhaps even blessed by divine providence. Lin-Manuel Miranda’s “Alexander Hamilton” was based on Ron Chernow’s 2004 biography, but McCullough helped clear the way for a heroic Hamilton. You could say that this was generational: that McCullough was too old to be hip to the identity politics that have come to dominate academia. That’s not quite accurate, though; the Founders had been attacked going back to the time of Columbia University’s Charles Beard and his fellow progressive historians of the early 20th century.Not that McCullough was entirely uncritical of capitalism or that he failed to appreciate government institutions. He tried to see the bright side. At an event at the Vineyard Haven public library on Martha’s Vineyard, he celebrated the idea that “anytime you start to get a little down about the state of American society or the state of American culture, keep in mind that today, still, there are more public libraries in the United States than there are McDonald’s. May it ever be so.” It seemed to me, at the time, a cheap shot against McDonald’s.McCullough’s doorstop biographies of John Adams and of President Truman got a lot of attention and won the author his two Pulitzer prizes. As someone who for years commuted by foot to Lower Manhattan from Brooklyn Heights, I also have sentimental affection for McCullough’s “The Great Bridge,” about the Brooklyn Bridge.My all-time favorite of McCullough’s works, however, is the slimmer “1776.” It ends: “Especially for those who had been with Washington and who knew what a close call it was at the beginning—how often circumstance, storms, contrary winds, the oddities or strengths of individual character had made the difference—the outcome seemed little short of a miracle.”Miraculous, in their way, too, were McCullough’s storytelling gifts, his work ethic, his voice, and the way they enlightened so many Americans. McCullough, by his words, connected his readers and listeners to the “strengths of individual character” that are the American genius.

McCullough’s Miracle: Recovering the Heroic Story of 1776

More from the New York Sun

‘Watch What I Do,’ Fetterman Says

What Is JD Vance Doing?

Mullin Promises Voter Fraud Crackdown After Trump’s National Address

More from the New York Sun

‘Watch What I Do,’ Fetterman Says

What Is JD Vance Doing?

Mullin Promises Voter Fraud Crackdown After Trump’s National Address

Hegseth Orders ‘Lessons Learned’ Review of Biden-Era Covid Vaccine Mandate

Marco Rubio’s Moment

Arizona Woman Sues Food Delivery Robot Company for Repeatedly Striking and Injuring Her

The Value of the Fedora in the Trucker Hat Era

United Airlines Backs Off From Allowing Free Ticket Changes for Customers Wanting To Avoid Trump Airport