Biden Might Yet Eye Reparations For U.S. Slavery

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

President Biden issued both a statement and a proclamation to mark February as Black History Month. Neither text made reference to reparations for slavery, though Mr. Biden, during the presidential campaign, backed the idea of a federal commission to study the issue of compensating the descendants of slaves.

That leaves an opening for Republicans, who have been missing in action on the reparations issue.

House Resolution 40, Representative Sheila Jackson Lee’s “Commission To Study and Develop Reparations Proposals for African Americans Act,” has backing from 162 cosponsors — all Democrats. Senate Resolution 40, the companion measure introduced by Senator Booker, is cosponsored by 16 Democrats and Senator Sanders of Vermont, an independent.

It’s not widely realized or articulated, but there is a conservative case to be made in favor of some modern version of the “40 acres and a mule” plan ordered by a Union general, William Sherman, in 1865.

Studies now show a vast disparity between black families and the rest of America when it comes to assets. A 2020 note from the Federal Reserve found white families had a median family wealth of $188,200 and an average family wealth of $983,400. For black families, median and average wealth, at $24,100 and $142,500, was less than 15% that of white families. Reparations could help rectify that, giving black voters more of an ownership stake in a rising stock market and in increasing home prices.

The potential cost to taxpayers of any reparations scheme is often raised as an objection. Mr. Biden is getting ready to borrow and spend about $4 trillion. If half of that sum, $2 trillion, were devoted to reparations, it would yield about $50,000 apiece for the roughly 40 million Americans who are descendants of black slaves in the United States. For a family of four, that’d be $200,000, enough to start a business, make a down payment on a house, or help pay for education.

If it seems like a hare-brained scheme, consider some of the other possible ways that the Biden administration is considering spending the money. Some of the proposals date back to the Gore vice presidency — windmills, electric cars, rural broadband, high-speed rail, raises for unionized teachers, loan forgiveness for people with graduate school debt, extended unemployment assistance to incentivize and subsidize not working.

Mr. Biden’s whole economic pitch — including his plan to double the capital gains tax — is built on a false dichotomy between “work” and “wealth.” More black business owners and stock-market millionaires would eventually mean more black opposition to attempts by Mr. Biden and others to raise taxes on capital.

If reparations seem an attractive alternative to other government spending options, they are also a preferred alternative to other potential ways of achieving racial comity. As a policy option, reparations probably beat, say, “defund the police and let crime run rampant,” or “have businesses and schools pay lots of money to diversity, equity, and inclusion consultants and functionaries to run mandatory training sessions that wind up just breeding resentment by those who sit through them.”

Another objection to reparations is the years that have passed since slavery. Yet racist laws and practices that descended from slavery persisted in parts of the United States well into the 20th century and are still felt today, as the wealth disparity suggests.

Mr. Biden may figure he has his hands full with the pandemic and economic recovery or climate change or China or some other priority and therefore doesn’t want to wade into the reparations issue. The racial disparities in pandemic death rates and in vaccination uptake, though, show that it’s difficult to tackle the pandemic without confronting the legacy of slavery. If Mr. Biden doesn’t get it done in his first term maybe Ron DeSantis or some other Republican can turn it into a 2024 campaign issue.

Beyond the partisan politics of it is an opportunity to counter cynicism. No sum can compensate for the scars of slavery. Dollars, though, come closer than what the Biden-Harris administration has so far been able to muster, which is just rhetoric.


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use