Doubts on Abortion Cloud Her Record

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

WASHINGTON – As doubts grow about her abortion views, Harriet Miers will face vigorous questioning on privacy rights and her qualifications for the Supreme Court, the chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee said yesterday.


Senator Specter, a Republican of Pennsylvania, said President Bush’s pick to replace retiring Justice O’Connor must show she can handle complicated legal issues and has not cut deals with the White House to overturn Roe v. Wade.


Ms. Miers’s nomination has caused division among conservatives, and a leader of the right said he will not be satisfied until it is clear whether Ms. Miers, a longtime Bush confidante who has never been a judge, would overturn the landmark 1973 abortion ruling.


“You can be an evangelical and you can be self-described pro-life. But it doesn’t tell us what she will do about a decision like Roe that has been set in stone now for over 30 years. And that’s the rub,” the president of the American Values Coalition, Gary Bauer, said.


Mr. Specter, noting that a justice has lifetime tenure, said, “If there are backroom assurances and if there are backroom deals and if there is something which bears upon a precondition as to how a nominee is going to vote, I think that’s a matter that ought to be known.”


Mr. Specter and the committee’s top Democrat, Senator Leahy of Vermont, are considering having Focus on the Family founder James Dobson testify at Ms. Miers’s confirmation hearings. Mr. Dobson has said he is confident Ms. Miers opposes abortion, based on private assurances from the White House.


Disputing that, Mr. Leahy said Ms. Miers assured him that she had not made any promises on how she would vote on Roe.


“If assurances were given of how any nominee – whether this nominee or anybody else – and somebody gives assurances how they’re going to vote in an upcoming case, I would vote against that person,” said Mr. Leahy, who appeared with Mr. Specter on ABC’s “This Week.”


In recent days, many conservatives have expressed outrage that Mr. Bush did not choose a nominee with a proven judicial track record, contending it was risky putting Ms. Miers on the court because she was a blank slate on issues such as abortion and the death penalty. Some activists have said she should withdraw her nomination. Mr. Bauer suggested that conservatives will not support Ms. Miers unless they have assurances that she would oppose Roe.


“The whole strategy here is the so-called stealth strategy,” he said. “And at the end of the day, the only ones who get fooled by it are conservatives.”


Commentator Pat Buchanan, a former presidential candidate, contended that Ms. Miers’s qualifications were “utterly nonexistent.” He criticized Mr. Bush for passing over a half dozen conservatives for a nominee who has never ruled on important decisions or expressed interest in constitutional law.


“What we’ve heard here is, ‘Trust, believe.’ Why should we take this risk?” Mr. Buchanan said on NBC’s “Meet the Press.”


Defending Ms. Miers, Texas Supreme Court Judge Nathan Hecht said Ms. Miers was going to overcome the criticism and would not step aside. He said the former corporate lawyer was an abortion opponent, but said that does not mean she would vote to overturn Roe. “Legal issues and personal issues are just two different things. Judges do it all the time,” he told “Fox News Sunday.”


Mr. Specter cautioned against a rush to judgment on Ms. Miers, saying she’s faced “one of the toughest lynch mobs ever.” But Ms. Miers will need to be able to justify to senators whether she is qualified in order to be confirmed, he said. “When you deal in constitutional law, you’re dealing in some very esoteric, complicated subjects that require a great deal of background,” Mr. Specter said. “The jurisprudence is very complicated, and I will be pressing her very hard on these issues.”


Messrs. Specter and Leahy said they will strive to hold confirmation hearings as soon as possible, perhaps before Thanksgiving, but their primary concern was to conduct a thorough investigation. “The standard is to do it right, not to do it fast,” Mr. Specter said.


Hoping to ascertain Ms. Miers’s views, Senate Democrats are pushing the White House to release reams of documents from the time Ms. Miers served under Mr. Bush as staff secretary, deputy chief of staff, and White House counsel. But Mr. Specter said he did not support such a request, agreeing with the White House that the material is covered by executive privilege.


“If somebody is going to function as White House counsel to the president of the United States, that person is going to have to be free to give advice without worrying that someday that advice is going to be scrutinized by some Senate committee,” he said.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use