Jurors Screen Film That Sparked Case Against Jackson

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

SANTA MARIA, Calif. – Jurors in the Michael Jackson child molestation trial yesterday watched the TV documentary that sparked the case, seeing the pop star hold hands with his accuser and talk about hosting sleepovers with children at his Neverland Ranch.


The documentary “Living With Michael Jackson” was shown after defense attorney Thomas Mesereau Jr. finished an opening statement in which he suggested the entertainer may testify and said authorities found no DNA evidence in the entertainer’s bedroom to support the charges. Mr. Jackson is not on the defense witness list.


Prosecutors say Mr. Jackson plied his accuser, then a 13-year-old cancer survivor, with alcohol and showed him sexually explicit images before molesting him at Neverland.


“Mr. Jackson will freely admit that he does read girlie magazines from time to time,” Mr. Mesereau said. “He absolutely does not show them to children.”


Jurors watched the documentary after prosecutors called its maker, British journalist Martin Bashir, to the stand. The documentary, taped in 2002 and aired in 2003, led to the investigation that ultimately resulted in the charges against Mr. Jackson.


During the viewing, Mr. Jackson dabbed his eyes with a tissue during a segment in which he says children are his reason for living.


As the jurors watched on a large screen in the hushed courtroom, some leaned forward in their seats, a few smiled or laughed when Mr. Jackson said humorous things, and a few bobbed their heads along with Mr. Jackson’s music. Some smiled when the video showed Mr. Jackson singing “smile while your heart is breaking” as he left a hotel.


Although the documentary is best known for Mr. Jackson’s comments about allowing children to sleep in his bed, it also exposed jurors to a sympathetic portrayal of Mr. Jackson. The singer is seen racing go-carts and climbing trees, as well as teaching Mr. Bashir how to “moonwalk.”


At one point, Mr. Jackson emotionally describes abuse that he claims he and his brothers received from their father, Joseph Jackson, during their days in the Jackson 5.


“I remember hearing my mother scream, ‘Joe, you’re going to kill him,’ ” Mr. Jackson says at one point.


The documentary also referred to Mr. Jackson’s relationships with adult women, and briefly showed the 2002 incident in which he dangled one of his children from a German hotel balcony.


In another scene, Mr. Jackson appears with the accuser and his brother and sister. The children do a dance routine in Mr. Jackson’s kitchen.


Later, the boy holds hands with Mr. Jackson and says the pop star is perpetually childlike and understands children.


“He’s really a child at heart,” the boy tells an interviewer. “You’re an adult when you want to be one.”


When the boy says that Mr. Jackson once told him and his brother, “If you love me, you’ll sleep in the bed,” Mr. Jackson tells the interviewer that the children slept in his bed and he slept on the floor in a sleeping bag.


Holding the boy’s hand tightly, Mr. Jackson says, “My greatest inspiration comes from kids. It’s all inspired by that level of purity. I see God in the face of children.”


After the viewing, Mr. Mesereau sought to have Mr. Bashir’s testimony and the documentary stricken when Mr. Bashir refused to say how many hours of videotape were recorded during the making of the program.


Judge Rodney Melville refused to strike the video or the testimony.


As Mr. Bashir was being peppered with questions by Mr. Mesereau, the witness’s attorney repeatedly invoked California’s shield law for reporters and the First Amendment, saying that as a journalist, Mr. Bashir did not have to answer questions about unpublished materials.


Mr. Bashir refused to answer about 30 times. Mr. Jackson appeared agitated when Mr. Bashir was on the stand, at one point putting out his arms as if to tell him to speak up.


Mr. Bashir was testifying in a near whisper. As Mr. Jackson left court, reporters asked him how he was feeling. He said “good,” then added “angry.” He thanked reporters and walked away.


In his opening statement, Mr. Mesereau earlier accused the prosecution of changing the dates of the alleged molestation because they were in conflict with an interview between child welfare workers and the family.


Mr. Mesereau also said the mother was using the criminal charges to build a civil case in order to get a payoff.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use