Jury Deliberates Libby’s Fate

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun
The eight women and four men heard 14 days of testimony, a full day of closing arguments and more than an hour of instructions from District Judge Reggie Walton before beginning their discussions.

The jurors include a former Washington Post reporter, an MIT-trained economist, a retired math teacher, a former museum curator, a law firm accountant, a Web architect and several retired or current federal workers. There are 10 whites and two blacks – unexpected in a city where blacks outnumber whites more than 2-to-1.

Mr. Libby, who was the chief of staff to Vice President Cheney, faces five felony counts that carry a combined top penalty of 30 years in prison. If convicted, Mr. Libby probably would be sentenced to far less under federal guidelines.

The trial provided behind-the-scenes details of the interaction between top reporters and government officials and of Mr. Cheney’s efforts to rebut criticism of him and the administration.

The investigation began with the public identification of CIA operative Valerie Plame on July 14, 2003, eight days after her husband, ex-ambassador Joseph Wilson publicly accused the Bush administration of distorting intelligence to push the nation into war with Iraq.

Months later, Mr. Libby told the FBI and a grand jury that he first learned that Ms. Plame worked for the CIA from Mr. Cheney on June 11. But he said that amid the press of war issues and other national security concerns he forgot that and was surprised to learn it from NBC Washington bureau chief Tim Russert on July 10 or 11. Thereafter he said he told reporters he had heard the information only from journalists and could not confirm it.

Mr. Russert testified he and Mr. Libby never discussed Ms. Plame. Judith Miller, who had been a reporter with The New York Times, testified Mr. Libby told her about Ms. Plame’s CIA job before the Russert conversation. Matt Cooper, then of Time magazine, testified Mr. Libby confirmed her employment for him. Six government officials testified they either told Mr. Libby about Ms. Plame’s job or discussed it with him between June 11 and July 10 or 11.

Judge Walton explained to the jurors that they must weigh the truth of several different statements by Mr. Libby in the various counts.

On the obstruction count, Judge Walton said they could find Mr. Libby guilty if they unanimously decided any one, or more, of three Mr. Libby statements were lies: that Mr. Russert asked Mr. Libby if Ms. Plame worked at CIA and said all the reporters knew it, that Mr. Libby was surprised to learn the Ms. Plame information from Mr. Russert or that Mr. Libby told Mr. Cooper he’d heard it from reporters but didn’t know it was true.

On one count of lying to the FBI, jurors could find Mr. Libby guilty if they found either or both of his statement about the Mr. Russert call were lies, Judge Walton explained. The other count of lying to the FBI hinges on Mr. Libby’s statement about the Mr. Cooper call.

On two counts of perjury, jurors would have to weigh various Mr. Libby statements to the grand jury about how he learned about Ms. Plame’s job and whom he told, including four separate statements in one count, Judge Walton said.

Prosecutors argued that Mr. Libby concocted lies to make his discussions of Ms. Plame with reporters appear to be innocent gossip so that he would not risk losing his job for giving them classified information without authorization.

The defense argued that Mr. Libby had an innocent lapse of memory, and his lawyer attempted to show that government witnesses also had memory flaws.
___
Associated Press writer Matt Apuzzo contributed to this report.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use