Kavanaugh Rage Is, In Essence, About Abortion

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

As she entered the room in her crisp blue suit, Christine Blasey Ford seemed nervous, and rightfully so. Initially hesitant to publicly accuse Judge Brett Kavanaugh of sexual assault decades ago, Ms. Ford appeared teary-eyed and vulnerable as she told her story to the United States Senate and to the nation.

Ms. Ford’s recitation of an incident that has “haunted” her most of her life came across as sincere. In a particularly moving response to questioning, the Laura Linney look-alike said that the moment most “indelibly” seared in her mind was the “uproarious laughter” of the older boys at her expense.

I have no doubt that Ford has been deeply affected by the misogynistic cruelty of high school boys when she was just 15. Nor do I doubt that someone whom she believes to be Brett Kavanaugh assaulted her in her youth. Her apparent fragility made clear she believes what she says.

But the science on the weakness and malleability of human memory and the fact that none of the witnesses that Ford has named corroborate her story raise concerning questions about the accuracy of the specific claims against Kavanaugh.

Judge Kavanaugh’s emotional defense of his character and indictment of the confirmation process was an important reminder that none of this is really about him or even Christine Blasey Ford.

It’s about abortion, plain and simple.

For years, progressives have wrongly regarded Justice Anthony Kennedy as the only thing standing between women and the back alley. So Democrats vowed to do whatever it took to stop President Trump’s nominee to replace Kennedy, even before Trump named a successor.

Enter Ford. In July, Senator Dianne Feinstein learned of Ford’s story. Had Senator Feinstein really been worried that the president had named a sexual predator to the Supreme Court, she should have explained to Ms. Ford the need to share the allegation with her colleagues confidentially. Having done that, Mrs. Feinstein should have convinced a bipartisan group of senators to ask the president to withdraw the nomination and select someone else. This approach would have been respectful of both Ms. Ford’s privacy and Judge Kavanaugh’s reputation. But she deliberately chose not to do that.


Because Senator Feinstein had no interest in the truth of the allegation. Ms. Feinstein’s interests were purely political: fire up the “resistance,” bring home a high-profile scalp for the #MeToo movement, and shore up the left flank in order to fend off a progressive Senate challenger.

How else to explain Ms. Feinstein’s invitation to actress Alyssa Milano, a leading #MeToo activist, to attend the hearing as her guest? How else to explain her repeated references to farcical claims that Judge Kavanaugh was part of a teenage gang rape ring?

Ms. Feinstein’s behavior makes clear she played Ms. Ford like a pawn. That is not a condemnation of Ms. Ford, it is a condemnation of Senator Feinstein. Saying so isn’t “survivor shaming,” it’s “Senate shaming.”

Let’s be honest: Senator Feinstein allowed two people and their families to be the subject of death threats and to be publicly humiliated and emotionally destroyed.

Ms. Feinstein and her Democratic colleagues don’t care whether they re-traumatized Ford, destroyed the reputation of a faithful public servant, or destroyed the credibility of our public institutions. Because, well, abortion.

Welcome to the Resistance.

Mrs. Braceras, a former commissioner on the United States Commission on Civil Rights, is a senior fellow at the Independent Women’s Forum. This column first appeared in the Boston Globe.

The New York Sun

© 2023 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use