McCain Wins South Carolina Primary

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

Senator McCain won a hard-fought South Carolina primary tonight, avenging a bitter personal defeat in a bastion of conservatism and gaining ground in an unpredictable race for the Republican presidential nomination. Democrats Senators Clinton and Obama split the spoils in Nevada caucuses marred by late charges of dirty politics.

“We’ve got a long way to go,” Mr. McCain said in an interview. He quickly predicted that his victory in the first southern primary would help him next week when Florida votes, and again on February 5 when more than two dozen states hold primaries and caucuses.

“This is one step on a long journey,” Mrs. Clinton told cheering supporters in Las Vegas. She captured the popular vote, but Mr. Obama edged her out for national convention delegates at stake, taking 13 to her 12.

Mr. Obama issued a statement that said he had conducted an “honest, uplifting campaign … that appealed to people’s hopes instead of their fears.”

If the Democrats had co-front-runners, the Republicans had none, and looked to the first southern state primary to begin winnowing an unwieldy field.

Mr. McCain defeated a former Arkansas governor, Michael Huckabee, in a close race in the state that snuffed out his presidential hopes eight years ago. The Arizonan was gaining 33% of the vote to just under 30% for his closest rival.

“It just took us a while. That’s all. Eight years is not a long time,” Mr. McCain said.

A former Tennessee senator, Fred Thompson, was in a struggle for third place with about 16%, after saying he needed a strong showing to sustain his candidacy. Another Republican, Rep. Duncan Hunter, dropped out even before the votes were tallied.

Interviews with South Carolina voters leaving their polling places indicated that Mr. McCain, an Arizona senator, and Mr. Huckabee, a former Arkansas governor, were dividing the Republican vote evenly. As was his custom, Mr. McCain was winning the votes of self-described independents.

South Carolina was the second half of a campaign double-header for Republicans.

A former Massachusetts governor, Mitt Romney, cruised to victory earlier in the day in the little-contested Nevada caucuses.

No matter the state, the economy was the top issue in all three races on the ballot.

Republicans in Nevada and South Carolina cited immigration as their second most-important concern.

Among Democrats in Nevada, health care was the second most-important issue followed by the Iraq war, which has dominated the race for months.

With three contests on the ballot, it was the busiest day of the presidential campaign to date, and fittingly enough for a pair of wide-open races, every contest produced a different winner.

Mr. Romney rolled to victory in Nevada Republican caucuses, winning roughly 50% of the vote in a multi-candidate field.

With a black man and a woman as the leading contenders, the Democratic race was history in the making — and increasingly testy, as well.

Before the votes were tallied, Mr. Obama was critical of President Clinton, telling reporters, “It’s hard to say what his intentions are. But I will say that he seems to be making a habit of mischaracterizing what I say.”

Mr. Obama’s campaign manager, David Plouffe, issued a written statement accused the Clinton campaign of “an entire week’s worth of false, divisive attacks designed to mislead caucus-goers and discredit the caucus itself.”

Mrs. Clinton declined to comment on the allegation.

Whatever the hard feelings, she told supporters they would fade by the fall general election campaign. “We will all be united in November,” she said, as the crowd chanted “HRC, HRC.”

Her campaign issued a statement citing numerous reports of voter intimidation. It also accused UNITE HERE, a union supporting Mr. Obama, of running a radio commercial that was “one of the most scurrilous smears in recent memory.” The ad, broadcast in Spanish, said Mrs. Clinton “does not respect our people” and called her shameless.

Interviews with Democratic caucus-goers indicated that Mrs. Clinton fashioned her victory by winning about half the votes cast by whites, and two-thirds support from Hispanics, many members of a Culinary Workers Union that had endorsed Mr. Obama. He won about 80% of the black vote.

Mr. Obama had pinned his Nevada hopes on an outpouring of support from the 60,000-member union. But it appeared that turnout was lighter than expected at nine caucuses established along the Las Vegas Strip, and some attending held signs reading, “I support my union. I support Hillary.”

Democrats looked next to South Carolina to choose between Mr. Obama, the most viable black candidate in history, and Mrs. Clinton, seeking to become the first woman to occupy the White House. The state is home to thousands of black voters, who are expected to comprise as much as half the Democratic electorate.

After that, the race goes national, with more than 20 states holding primaries and caucuses on February 5 and 1,678 national Democratic convention delegates at stake.

The split Democratic verdict in Nevada resulted from the proportional manner in which delegates were awarded. Mr. Obama emerged with one more than Mrs. Clinton because he ran strongly in rural areas.

Overall, Mrs. Clinton leads the delegates race with 236, including separately chosen party and elected officials known as superdelegates. Mr. Obama has a total of 136, and a former senator, John Edwards, has 50.

Mr. Romney struck first on the day among the Republicans.

The former Massachusetts governor learned of his Nevada victory when his wife Ann announced it on the public address system of his chartered jet. “Keep ’em coming. Keep ’em coming,” he said.

Mr. Romney had campaigned for months to win early contests in Iowa and New Hampshire, and his candidacy was in trouble when he lost both. He retooled his appeal to the voters in the days leading to the Michigan primary, though, focusing on the economy and trumpeting his experience as a businessman.

En route to Florida, he presented reporters with his ambitious economic stimulus plan, $233 billion in all. It includes tax rebates as well as tax cuts for individuals, as well as tax cuts for businesses.

Nevada Republicans said the economy and illegal immigration were their top concerns, according to a survey of voters entering the caucuses. Mr. Romney led among voters who cited both issues.

Mormons gave Mr. Romney about half his votes. He is hoping to become the first member of his faith to win the White House. Alone among the Republican contenders, Rep. Ron Paul of Texas aired television ads in Nevada.

Nearly complete returns showed Mr. Romney winning more than 50% of the vote, with Messrs. Paul and McCain far behind vying for second. Messrs. Thompson and Huckabee trailed.

Mr. Romney also won at least 17 of the 31 Republican National Convention delegates at stake. Messrs. McCain and Paul won at least four apiece, while Messrs. Thompson and Huckabee each won two. Mr. Hunter and Mayor Giuliani each won one delegate — the first of the campaign for the former New York mayor.

Nevada offered more delegates — 31 versus 24 — but far less appeal to the Republican candidates than South Carolina, a primary that has gone to the party’s eventual nominee every four years since 1980.

That made it a magnet for Mr. Thompson, who staked his candidacy on a strong showing, as well as for Messrs. Romney, McCain, and Huckabee.

Mr. McCain, a former Vietnam prisoner of war, appealed to a large population of military veterans in South Carolina, and stressed his determination to rein in federal spending as he worked to avenge a bitter defeat in the 2000 primary.

Mr. Huckabee reached out to evangelical Christian voters, hoping to rebound from a string of disappointing showings since his victory in the January 3 Iowa caucuses.

Mr. Romney campaigned on a pledge to help restore the state’s economy, much as he did in winning Michigan.

In South Carolina, the economy and immigration were cited as top issues, with more than half the voters saying illegal immigrants should be deported. Conservatives and white evangelical voters turned out in heavy numbers, according to the polling place interviews.

Survey data in both states were from polls conducted for The Associated Press and the television networks by Edison Media Research and Mitofsky International.

South Carolina primary voters coped with equipment difficulty and bad weather. Election officials in the area around Myrtle Beach brought out paper ballots after some electronic voting machines failed to work properly. Snow fell in the northern part of the state, which has little snow removal equipment.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use