Obama Running on McGovern Rules as Race Begins for 2012

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

WASHINGTON — I see that President Barack Obama has filed as a candidate for reelection in 2012. I had suggested that he get to work early on his presidential library and forgo the race, but he is insistent. Well, I tried.

Though some in the press are covering for him, his announcement is the earliest of any modern president. It continues a trend that began in 1972. That was when Senator McGovern captured the Democratic presidential nomination, though he lost in the autumn of that year in a squeaker. Richard Nixon stole the election, 47,167,319 to 29,168,509. Tricky Dick got 60.7% of the vote, the largest in history except for Lyndon Johnson’s 61.1%. Watergate changed history.

Using what came to be called the McGovern reforms in the 1972 Democratic Convention, the very same Mr. McGovern captured the nomination. The anti-Communist wing of the party was locked out, leading to pictures of a disgruntled president of the AFL-CIO, George Meany, sunning his capacious stomach poolside as the party that once welcomed him was preparing to nominate Mr. McGovern. Thus did the Reagan Democrats begin to crystallize. And thus began the trend, the era of the chronic campaigner. Since 1972 the Democratic Party has nominated a chronic campaigner every time.

Mr. McGovern had been running since 1968 when he declared his candidacy three weeks before the convention and ran as a stand-in for the assassinated Robert Kennedy. No one from the Democratic Establishment noticed anything afoot. They granted the New Politics, whose members had created such a mad pothering at the 1968 convention, something called the Commission on Party Structure and Delegate Selection for the 1972 Convention.

When Mr. McGovern was made chairman of the Reform Commission, as it came to be called, the Establishment still did not take heed. Mr. McGovern had obviously been running since 1968, but as Teddy White noted in 1973, “…no one considered McGovern a serious Presidential contender, but he was everyone’s personal favorite…. Robert Kennedy had called him ‘the most decent man in the Senate.’”

Well, the Democratic Party has been stuck with the chronic campaigner since 1972. The McGovern reforms remain for the most part in place. So if you have the time, you too can become a chronic campaigner. Jimmy Carter ran the theretofore most grueling campaign in history and was lucky to have Gerald Ford as an opponent and Watergate. There was not a village too small for him to visit. If two people gathered on a street corner, the chances are Jimmy was there with his hand out and his idiot smile. The next chronic campaigner to win the presidency was Bill Clinton, and he is still campaigning for something. Most recently MSNBC named him “President of the World: The Clinton Phenomenon.”

Mr. Obama has been running for president since his first day in the Senate. All through his presidency he has been running for reelection. His filing the other day was a mere formality. The problem with the chronic campaigner is that, though he is a swell candidate, he is a lousy chief executive. He cannot sit still, as in an office. My guess is that Mr. Obama has spent less time in the White House than his predecessor. Now he will be on the campaign trail full time.

So maybe Congressman Paul Ryan will run the country. In unveiling his budget for 2012 he has shown that he is serious about facing the tremendous budget crunch ahead. Some conservatives are dismayed that his budget still adds $8 trillion in debt. It does not balance the budget for 20 years. That just emphasizes how deep a hole we are in. Mr. Ryan’s plan is the most serious effort to reform government since…well since the chronic campaigner came along.

Spending is now, under Obama, at 24% of GDP and will go higher. Mr. Ryan wants to bring it down to 20%, about where it has traditionally been in modern times. If we stick with Mr. Obama’s spending we shall be at one with Greece. But cuts are not enough. Mr. Ryan knows that to balance the budget the economy must grow. He will lower the burden on personal and corporate taxes to 25%, and he uses dynamic scoring rather than static scoring to show growth from his tax cut rather than loss of revenue. Revenue under Ryan’s budget will be at 17.9%, about where it has been in modern times, and during our periods of economic expansion.

So our chronic campaigner filed for reelection and left town for the campaign trail. Ryan offered a budget for 2012 and a vision. The race is on.

Mr. Tyrrell, editor in chief of the American Spectator, is a contributing editor of The New York Sun.


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use