Rangel’s Jibe at President Draws Support From Democrats

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

WASHINGTON – Responding to statements made last week by Rep. Charles Rangel, the Republican National Committee urged Democratic leaders yesterday to denounce the New York congressman’s comparison of President Bush to the late Theophilus “Bull” Connor, the Birmingham, Ala., police commissioner who came to symbolize Southern racism in the 1960s.


The Republican request for repudiation, however, met with expressions of support for Mr. Rangel’s statement, particularly from black Democratic leaders in New York. The Reverend Al Sharpton came out in support of Mr. Rangel’s analysis, and another member of the city’s congressional delegation, Major Owens, a Democrat of Brooklyn, denounced Mr. Bush as “even more diabolical” than Connor.


At a town hall meeting of the Congressional Black Caucus held in Washington last Thursday, Mr. Rangel, a Democrat of Harlem, faulted Mr. Bush for his response to Hurricane Katrina. Lambasting the president for being insensitive to blacks affected by the storm, Mr. Rangel said, to an appreciative audience: “George Bush is our Bull Connor.”


In 1963, Connor, while Birmingham’s police commissioner, turned attack dogs and fire hoses on blacks, including Martin Luther King Jr., demonstrating for equal rights.


Yesterday, Mr. Rangel, reached by phone, elaborated on his comments, saying he made the comparison because Mr. Bush, like Connor, had become a rallying point for America’s blacks.


“For decades in the ’20s and ’30s, black folks were killed, maimed, tortured, and lynched in the South,” Mr. Rangel told The New York Sun. “And the good people did nothing about it. And then came the blowing up of children in the churches – Emmett Till, and Bull Connor, with the dogs lashing out against the young people, and the fire hoses.” Emmett Till was the black teenager whose 1955 murder in Mississippi intensified the civil rights movement.


“And because of the Bull Connors,” Mr. Rangel said, “the American people said enough is enough.” Connor, Mr. Rangel said, “woke up the country in terms of racism, and maybe the indifference of Bush can wake up the country in terms of not having tax cuts but ending poverty.”


Mr. Rangel’s analysis provoked outrage across the aisle yesterday, as a spokeswoman for the Republican National Committee, Tracey Schmitt, responded: “By making such an outrageous comparison, Rangel is simply emulating the hateful divisiveness of the past.”


“President Bush,” Ms. Schmitt told the Sun, “remains more committed than ever to expanding access to the American dream, and Democrat leaders should repudiate such hateful attacks.”


A spokeswoman for the Democratic National Committee, Amaya Smith, responded: “I think the bigger issue here that the RNC is not addressing is that the president and his administration – that their policies made life harder for African-Americans. And not just African-Americans, but working Americans around the country as well.” When asked whether the committee repudiated Mr. Rangel’s comments or stood by them, Ms. Smith declined to comment, referring the Sun to her previous statement.


Support for Mr. Rangel’s comparison was explicit among Democratic leaders in New York City as the party’s nominee for mayor, Fernando Ferrer, weighed in. “George W. Bush and the conservative Republican policies he champions have consistently hurt working people throughout our country and our city,” a spokeswoman for the candidate, Christy Setzer, said yesterday. “President Bush is an affront to the Democratic values Congressman Rangel and Fernando Ferrer share.”


A prominent black activist, Rev. Sharpton, also supported Mr. Rangel’s Bush-as-Connor comparison. “I think that the statement clearly says that if there is a person that is a symbol that many blacks organize around and organize against in this generation, it would be Bush – as it was with one generation and Connor,” Rev. Sharpton said. “In that sense I agree with him,” he said of Mr. Rangel.


“Clearly Bush has become that, especially after Katrina,” Rev. Sharpton said. “We’ve gone from fire hoses to levees.”


As Rev. Sharpton expressed support for Mr. Rangel’s comments, another senior member of the Congressional Black Caucus and of New York’s congressional delegation, Mr. Owens, said he thought Mr. Rangel hadn’t taken the metaphor far enough.


“Bull Connor didn’t even pretend that he cared about African-Americans,” Mr. Owens said. “You have to give it to George Bush for being even more diabolical.”


“With his faith-based initiatives,” Mr. Owens added, “he made it appear that he cared about black Americans. Katrina has exposed that as a big lie.”


As a result, Mr. Rangel “is on the right track,” Mr. Owens said. “This is worse than Bull Connor,” he added.


A Democrat who represents Brooklyn on New York’s City Council, Charles Barron, concurred with that sentiment. “I think that’s an insult to Connor,” he said of Mr. Rangel’s statement. “George Bush is worse, because he has more power and he’s more destructive to our people than Bull Connor will ever be.”


For example, Mr. Barron said, “A KKK without power is not as bad as a George Bush with power.”


“To be a racist in the richest, most powerful country in the world is lethal,” Mr. Barron added. “Look what he’s doing to communities of color all over the world,” the council member said of Mr. Bush. “He’s a lethal racist.”


“What he did in New Orleans – I mean, that’s worse than what Bull Connor did in his entire career as a racist in the South,” Mr. Barron said. “Look at these neighborhoods before Katrina hit. Bush made that community what it is. Katrina did the rest, in partnership with Bush, to deliver the final blow.”


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use