Trump, JFK Vowed Tax Cuts <br>From the Same Platform <br>— Literally and Economically

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

How fitting that Donald Trump made his most important economic policy speech at the Economic Club of New York. That’s where, 54 years ago, President Kennedy unveiled a dramatic tax-cut plan to revive the long-stagnant U.S. economy. He proposed lowering marginal tax rates for all taxpayers and reducing the corporate tax. He advised lowering the top tax rate to 65% from 91% and closing tax loopholes. Five times during the speech he used the word “incentives.”

In perhaps the most famous line from that path-breaking speech, JFK said: “In short, it is a paradoxical truth that tax rates are too high today and tax revenues too low, and the soundest way to raise revenues in the long run is to cut rates now.”

Kennedy had already in 1962 lowered investment taxes on business. After his tragic assassination, his broader tax proposals were passed into law in early 1964. And they worked. The U.S. economy grew by roughly 5% yearly for nearly eight years.

Almost 20 years later, Ronald Reagan launched a 30% tax-rate reduction to save the economy from the high-unemployment, high-inflation 1970s. Reagan acknowledged many times that he was following in Kennedy’s footsteps. Under the Gipper, tax rates were slashed to 28% from 70%, corporate taxes were cut, and numerous loopholes were closed.

And the American economy grew mostly between 4% and 5% percent annually for over 25 years.

By the way, both men, Kennedy and Reagan, followed a simple growth model of what I call tax cuts and King Dollar. Both men also reached across the aisle to garner bipartisan support for their plans.

This past week, Mr. Trump went a long way toward joining their ranks. Speaking before the Economic Club of New York, he delivered a positive, optimistic growth message that falls squarely inside the JFK-Reagan model.

“My economic plan,” he said, “rejects the cynicism that our labor force will keep declining, that our jobs will keep leaving, and that our economy will never grow as it did once before.” Optimism.

Mr. Trump established a goal of 4% economic growth, which would double the stagnant rate of the past 15 years. The centerpiece of his plan is a reduction in business tax rates for large and small firms to 15% from the current uncompetitive rates of between 35% and 40%. He offered immediate expensing for new investment and a 10% repatriation rate to incentivize American firms overseas to bring $2.5 trillion home.

High business taxes are the biggest obstacle to a return to rapid economic growth. Abundant research has shown that the best way to raise wages and create jobs is to slash business taxes. Within five years a business tax cut will pay for itself, and then some.

Importantly, Mr. Trump plans to reduce individual tax rates with three new brackets of 12%, 25%, and 33%. He would cap deductions for the wealthy and close special-interest loopholes. Middle-income wage earners will be the biggest beneficiaries of these reforms.

To cap it off, Mr. Trump will roll back out-of-control regulations, unleash American energy, and abolish the Obamacare failure.

Following the successes of the JFK and Reagan tax reforms, Trump’s strategy is likely to generate between 4% to 5% growth over time. A rising tide will lift all boats.

The contrast between the presidential contenders could not be starker. Hillary Clinton would raise taxes on so-called rich people, corporations, capital gains, financial transactions, and inheritance. Has there ever been an example where America has taxed its way into prosperity? Never.

Mr. Trump has an economic-recovery-and-prosperity plan. Mrs. Clinton has an austerity-recession plan. Historically, in presidential elections, the optimistic growth plan nearly always wins.

That said, Mr. Trump’s view of monetary policy, especially the dollar, needs to be resolved. At the Economic Club of New York, the GOP nominee charged that the Fed is being “totally controlled politically.” Elsewhere he has stated that Fed chairman, Janet Yellen, is keeping interest rates ultra-low in a political effort to boost Democratic fortunes. I disagree.

Mrs. Yellen doesn’t control the Fed monolithically. And the real debate about interest rates is going on inside the Fed.

True enough, the Fed needs radical reforms. In particular, it needs to replace its failed forecasting models and be rid of the academics who overwhelm the Fed system. But as New York Sun’s editor, Seth Lipsky, keeps reminding us, the best way to depoliticize the Fed is to develop a standard of value to make the dollar strong, reliable, and stable. In other words, a monetary rule.

JFK and Reagan’s growth model included tax cuts and a steady dollar. Mr. Trump has taken a gigantic step toward restoring prosperity with his tax-cut centered fiscal policy. Hopefully he will soon turn to a sound-dollar policy to bolster the growth impact of lower tax rates and regulations.

And hopefully then he will pound away on all this on the campaign trail.


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use