Lawyer: Evidence From Wiretaps Won’t Be Used in Suit Over Detentions

The government will not seek to use any evidence it may have gleaned from wiretapping in its defense against a lawsuit filed by Muslim men over their detention in the period following September 11, 2001, a Department of Justice trial attorney said in a letter submitted to federal court in Brooklyn.Lawyer Stephen Handler wrote in the letter filed Monday that he had not reviewed any conversations between the Muslim men and their attorneys. He also pledged that he would not seek to introduce as evidence any attorney client conversation that may have been intercepted.Mr. Handler refused to say whether he is aware if any such spying occurred. The magistrate judge in the case, Steven Gold, had previously ordered Mr. Handler to disclose whether the trial team and any potential witnesses – who may include a former attorney general, John Ashcroft – were aware of intercepted attorney-client conversations. Although Mr. Handler said in court that he was not aware of any eavesdropping, he has since rescinded that answer. In Monday’s letter, Mr. Handler stated that any denial of knowledge of eavesdropping could “itself reveal classified information.”The back and forth between the government and lawyers for the Center for Constitutional Rights, which represents the men, has occurred against the backdrop of a similar line of questioning in Washington. Last Friday, the Department of Justice indicated that attorney-client conversations were not “categorically excluded from interception” under the National Security Agency’s warrantless wiretap program, according to news reports of the Department of Justice’s written responses to dozens of questions from lawmakers.At least one legal observer said there was no reason that any government eavesdropping would affect the present litigation in Brooklyn.“When you talk about the NSA program, it is just assumed that the government is not going to be using it for any courtroom situation,” the former deputy assistant U.S. attorney general who established the Justice Department’s antiterrorism unit, Victoria Toensing, said. “It is being used for intelligence and matters of national security and protection.”Ms. Toensing added that the Justice Department has traditionally made an effort to keep trial lawyers apart from its surveillance efforts, to prevent knowledge of eavesdropping from tainting courtroom efforts.The Muslim men whose lawyers suspect to be under surveillance were detained for months after the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, before being deported. Some have accused their jailors of cruelty in the lawsuit filed in 2002. None of the men were accused of any terror-related charges. At least three of the men are currently in Toronto with their lawyers for further deposition, a spokesman for the Center for Constitutional Rights said, adding that the center would not comment on Mr. Handler’s letter until the judge has responded.

Lawyer: Evidence From Wiretaps Won’t Be Used in Suit Over Detentions

Lawyer: Evidence From Wiretaps Won’t Be Used in Suit Over Detentions

More from the New York Sun

‘Operation Economic Outcast’: Bessent Aims At Iran But Plan Has Scant Details, Vague Deadline

Congresswoman Condemns Hasan Piker After He Says Jews ‘Singularly’ Supporting Israel Invite Violence, As Senate Candidate El-Sayed Backs Streamer’s Free Speech Rights

California Attorney General Calls Off Settlement Talks With Paramount As Hollywood Pressure Builds To Resolve Merger Lawsuit

D.C. Bar To Weigh Complaint Filed Against Chief Justice Roberts Over Millions Paid to His Wife for Law Firm Recruiting

Iran Places $10 Million Bounty on Barron Trump, Saying He Is Being ‘Fully Monitored’

Mamdani’s Grocery Stores Violate Civil Rights of Minority-Owned Businesses, New Suit Claims

The Art of Baseball’s Bygone, Boundless Joy

Existing White House Bunker May Undercut Trump’s Ballroom Lawsuit

More from the New York Sun

‘Operation Economic Outcast’: Bessent Aims At Iran But Plan Has Scant Details, Vague Deadline

Congresswoman Condemns Hasan Piker After He Says Jews ‘Singularly’ Supporting Israel Invite Violence, As Senate Candidate El-Sayed Backs Streamer’s Free Speech Rights

California Attorney General Calls Off Settlement Talks With Paramount As Hollywood Pressure Builds To Resolve Merger Lawsuit

D.C. Bar To Weigh Complaint Filed Against Chief Justice Roberts Over Millions Paid to His Wife for Law Firm Recruiting

Iran Places $10 Million Bounty on Barron Trump, Saying He Is Being ‘Fully Monitored’

Mamdani’s Grocery Stores Violate Civil Rights of Minority-Owned Businesses, New Suit Claims

The Art of Baseball’s Bygone, Boundless Joy

Existing White House Bunker May Undercut Trump’s Ballroom Lawsuit