Light at the End of the Water Tunnel: A Theme Park Is Coming
This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

A visit to the Big Apple always promised a great adventure: Times Square, Coney Island, the Empire State Building. There was never a need for some trumped-up theme park in the land of Trump himself.
Until now.
In the latest bit of suburban creep into the nation’s largest city, a family themed water park is due before summer 2007 on a piece of Randalls Island parkland at the juncture of the East and Harlem rivers, under the vast Triborough Bridge.
The city hopes to lure more than 1.3 million visitors a year to the $168 million attraction that will boast water slides rising 80 feet into the skyline.
So are the five boroughs going Six Flags? A little bit, yes. And not everybody is pleased.
“The citizens of New York like the Brooklyn Bridge,” a performance artist who has waged a long (and losing) battle against New York’s commercialization, Billy Tallen, said. “The consumers prefer the water parks. We insist on being citizens, not consumers.”
The water park is just the latest indignity for Mr. Tallen and others who fondly recall the corner tavern, the mom and pop drugstore, the local coffee shop. These days, it’s more likely a Starbucks (159 locations in the city) or a TGIFriday’s (a dozen spots, including one on 42nd Street near the Red Lobster). Last year, a 7-Eleven opened on Park Avenue South at 23rd Street – the first new Manhattan franchise for the 24-hour stores since 1982.
“And Coney Island is going to be turned into another suburban development,” Mr.Tallen said, fearful of an $83 million redevelopment plan announced last year for the colorful Brooklyn beachfront.
The taming of Times Square is a fait accompli, with adult entertainment emporiums like Peepland and Show World giving way to kid-friendly fare and a comedy club. And “The Shops at Columbus Circle” is a highfalutin name for a (gasp!) mall, with outlets for J. Crew and Sephora.
But city officials and developers portrayed the 26-acre water park – an unlikely attraction in an unlikely location – as more boon than bane for both the citizens and consumers of New York.
“This is good news,” the parks commissioner, Adrian Benepe, one of the park’s boosters, said. “It has a potential to be a huge draw. We hope to be building a park for the 21st century on Randalls Island.”
The water park, designed by the New York State-based Aquatic Development Group, is a virtual done deal. The city’s Franchise and Concession Review Committee must still sign off on a proposed 35-year lease with Aquatic Development, but all the other steps in the process are finished. The site is easily reachable by car, bus, or footbridges.
And so New Yorkers will now have access to an amenity previously found only in locations like Scotrun, Pa., or Mason, Ill., or Grapevine, Texas.
The New York attraction will include wave pools, action rivers, wading pools, and plenty of slides. A seven-acre indoor beach will give New Yorkers a year-round attraction; Coney Island, in contrast, is strictly seasonal (except for those Polar Bear Club swimmers who take an annual winter dip in the Atlantic).
A water park consultant and president of Hotel & Leisure Advisors, David Sangree, said that the vast majority of the nation’s 71 water parks are located far from urban centers.
Wisconsin, with 30, is the state with the most water parks.
The New York facility would operate under unique circumstances. The new breed of water parks are typically attached to hotels, with admission reserved for guests only. The New York operation, since it’s on city parkland, will work with day passes and without a hotel.
It took seven years for the city to take the plunge on the water park. The plan was proposed in 1999 by Mayor Giuliani as a 12-acre facility. Seven years later, under the Bloomberg administration, the light at the end of the water tunnels is here.
The man who spent two decades as parks commissioner, Henry Stern, was less surprised by word of the burgeoning water park than most New Yorkers. He sorted through various proposals for Randalls Island, including a ski jump, while in office.
“Tennis courts, stadium, concert hall, golf course – people see land, and they want to build,” Mr. Stern says. “They salivate.”
Since its purchase from the local American Indians in 1637, Randalls Island served as a burial ground for the indigent, a home for juvenile delinquents, an asylum for alcoholics, and a rest home for Civil War veterans. After the island was designated a city park in 1933, its high points came as a sports and concert venue.
In 1936, President Roosevelt attended the opening ceremonies for a stadium on the island. The Olympic trials were held as the first event, with Jesse Owens warming up for the Berlin Games with victories in the 100 meters and the long jump.
Pele played there as a member of the New York Cosmos in the 1970s. The Dave Matthews Band is one of the musical headliners who played there in recent years. And by next summer, several hundred thousand people will splash and slide their way around Randalls.
As for Mr. Stern, he offered another suggestion.
“I think it would be no problem if it was left alone,” he said. “It doesn’t have to be a happening. It’s an open space, an island in the heart of the city.”

