Mafia Specter Hangs Over Little Italy
This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The red-white-and-green tinsel arches are back over Mulberry Street, along with the sizzling mounds of sausage and peppers and the warm zeppole dusted with powdered sugar. But at the Feast of San Gennaro in downtown Manhattan this year there’s also something unsavory in the air: the taint of organized crime.
Nearly a decade after Mayor Giuliani said he purged New York’s largest street fair of Mafia control, a witness at a Brooklyn mob trial testified this summer that the president of the feast’s board, restaurateur Perry Criscitelli, was a soldier in the Bonanno crime family. Mr. Criscitelli resigned.
The American Mafia was born on the streets where the San Gennaro festival draws a million visitors over 11 days. The feast features blocks of Italian food stands and a religious procession celebrating the patron saint of Naples, the backdrop to Vito Corleone’s assassination of the Mafioso Fanucci in “The Godfather: Part II.”
Organized crime shows that it has a way of hanging on, even as prosecutors and other officials announce they have cleaned up enterprises such as trucking or construction, said Jerry Capeci, a mob expert who writes an organized crime column for The New York Sun.
“It’s even harder to get the mob out from its roots,” he said.
In the latest attempt to assure the festival’s uprightness, city officials announced that a former federal prosecutor would join the board of directors and monitor the festival on behalf of Mayor Bloomberg. They said the appointment of Nelson Boxer, who prosecuted one of the original San Gennaro corruption cases, was a reaction to negative publicity and not an indication they were concerned about renewed mob control.
“It was really a proactive measure, not because I’m suggesting that there is any issue,” said Rose Gill Hearn, head of the city’s Department of Investigation.
She said the courtroom testimony about the festival president’s alleged ties to organized crime “had nothing to do with the feast itself.”
Mr. Criscitelli, the president, did not respond to a message left at the restaurant that houses his office. His attorney declined to comment on the allegations made against him in court.
Vendors operating the plywood stands set up outside Mulberry Street’s stretch of red-sauce Italian restaurants dismissed claims about Mafia involvement in the feast. “The mob? Who’s the mob?” asked John Persco, 69, as he turned a row of pork sausages.
Festival spokesman Bob Liff said there were concerns that participants in the feast were being tarred with mob allegations just because they are Italian-American.
But for the tourists strolling among rows of chocolate-dipped cannolis and piles of broccoli rabe yesterday afternoon, mob involvement was a given – and nothing to worry about.