New York Rolls Out Red Carpet for Migrants, Spurring Resentment 

The immigration-industrial complex — a web of Democratic politicians, immigration lawyers, and nonprofits that survive on public funding — pushes relentlessly for more money and more ‘rights’ for migrants.

Spencer Platt/Getty Images
The Roosevelt Hotel, which closed three years ago, at midtown Manhattan on May 15, 2023. Spencer Platt/Getty Images

Democrats’ new rule: If you’re not a migrant, go to the back of the line.

Gary Moretti and his fiancée booked 30 rooms at the Crossroads Hotel at Newburgh, New York, for their bridesmaids and guests for a June 24 wedding. But Mayor Adams’ migrant-first policy demolished their plans.

Over the last two weeks, Mr. Adams has rolled out a scheme to bus hundreds of migrants to upscale motels at Newburgh, Orangetown, and Yonkers, pleading that New York City is out of space. 

It didn’t matter that many of the motel rooms were already occupied or booked. Money talks. New York City pays above-market rates to house migrants, averaging $8,000 per room, per month, taxpayers be damned. 

The motels acted fast to clear their rooms.

“We had a legal contract to have those rooms,” Mr. Moretti said.

People staying at the Ramada Inn at Yonkers were told to clear out as well. Up to 100 migrant families are expected there within a week. Savannah Harp, who’s been living there with her 18-month-old son, resents that she’s had to pay for her room, while the migrants displacing her will get rooms for free.

Big-city Democrats like Mr. Adams give migrants top priority. Protest and you’re called “racist” or “xenophobic.”

Even so, some local leaders are fighting back against Mr. Adams’ takeover of hotels and motels in their counties.

Rockland and Orange counties are in court, arguing that Mr. Adams doesn’t have the right to set up shelters outside New York City.

Other counties are putting Mr. Adams on notice to not even try it. Nassau County’s executive, Bruce Blakeman, a Republican, made it clear, “we are not a sanctuary county.”

The battle unfolding in New York will likely be repeated in many locales. Connecticut alerted towns to prepare for migrants.

The immigration-industrial complex — a web of Democratic politicians, immigration lawyers, and nonprofits that survive on public funding — pushes relentlessly for more money and more “rights” for migrants.

Mr. Adams plans to house migrants in upstate hotels and motels for up to four months, with shuttle service provided three times a day to wherever they want to go. What a deal.

Democrats promised migrants sanctuary from immigration law enforcement, luxury accommodations, three meals a day, and health and legal services. Now they express surprise at the deluge of people heading to New York City, and insist all counties share the burden.

The New York Civil Liberties Union is suing Rockland and Orange counties, claiming the counties’ resistance amounts to “xenophobic harassment and discrimination.” That’s a cheap shot and untrue.

It’s not about race. It’s about money. Caring for migrants will force counties to cut services to their own residents.

Mr. Adams’ city budget for the coming fiscal year is proof. It cuts every department, including police protection and education, to offset spending on migrants.

The generous handouts to migrants are also causing resentment.

A Hispanic-American woman from Port Chester who has three kids and works cleaning houses said she’s furious to see migrants getting free housing. Why not her family, she asks.

Where is New York’s governor, Kathy Hochul? Mostly MIA. Her predecessor, Andrew Cuomo, says Ms. Hochul should “come down here and pick up these people and disperse them across the state.” That’s ridiculous.

The answer isn’t to foist the problem on other communities. It’s to stop making New York a magnet for migrants.

Democrats don’t get that. Last week, Mr. Adams announced that the landmark Roosevelt Hotel on East 45th Street and Vanderbilt Avenue will become the city’s migrant welcoming center and large shelter. 

Movies such as “The French Connection” and “Wall Street” were filmed there. The lobby is exquisite. A security guard told the New York Post, “the migrants are going to think they came to like Hollywood or something.”

Upscale lodging — whether it’s in Manhattan or along the Hudson — encourages migrants to make New York their destination. Worse, it sends a message to the rest of us, including Gary Moretti and his bride, that we’re saps.

Tell Mr. Adams to house migrants in barracks and tents and provide only bare necessities. Be humane, but not stupid.


Correction: This story has been updated to reflect the updated status of homeless veterans in upstate New York motels.

The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use