New York Loses Its Grip as a Political Hotspot

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

New Yorkers are feeling a severe case of heat withdrawal. They were used to being the red-hot center of American news and opinion. Suddenly they’re flyover country, relics from a dying tribe, seedy and unloved. They are as forlorn as those fiery partisan books that once pulsed with an angry beat on the best-seller list and now linger on the remainder tables in Barnes & Noble.


The psychiatrist Brooks Morgan says that Senator Kerry’s defeat, coming on the heels of the Yankees’ collapse in the playoffs against the Red Sox, plunged many of her patients into near-catatonic distress.


“In my whole 40 years of practice here I have never heard patients as bereft by a result as this,” she told me on the phone. “There was a feeling in session after session of the insult to one’s tribe, a loss of purpose and direction. For men, their sports team being beaten at the same time made them feel New York is no longer the command center, no longer the winning city they identify with or that so many people move here to find.”


Two weeks after the election, the erstwhile power center of the universe has heaved itself up from the shrink’s couch and trudged on, but it’s still wearing dark glasses.


What makes it difficult is all the political news booming away out there. President Bush’s Cabinet reshuffle is like a percussion band playing in the room next door when you’re trying to sleep. All that crashing and banging of big careers and exiting reputations – will somebody please turn it off? Don’t they know politics is over? Can’t they take a goddamn breather from running the world?


The purging of the CIA is clearly the story of the hour, but the only way to read it is as a novel. Everyone is too tired now to want to yammer about how much the legacy of Colin Powell has been bruised or work up appropriate bipartisan admiration for Condoleezza Rice’s career climb. Racetorn Alabama to Thomas Jefferson’s seat of global influence is a great American journey, okay? Now please turn the light off.


The small quotidian things are what people want in the winded city. Cut off the news, rent the DVD of “Doctor Zhivago,” surf the Web for a bargain holiday. Focus on trivia. Serious women of purpose had a nervous breakdown on Sunday night when they found ABC’s “Desperate Housewives” was off the air for two weeks. News anchors who had to spend a heroic year as the only mortals on the planet who couldn’t voice an opinion are sullen now with their perceived irrelevance. They refuse to sing for their suppers when less mood-sensitive guests at press gatherings ask them for a political update.


As one of them burst out the other day when I inquired about the Cabinet shakeup, “We analyzed it! We parsed it. We psychoanalyzed it! We did their wives, their aides, their psychographics! We did the effect of prep school and their fathers! And none of it mattered! All I want to talk about now is the new diet pill.”


At a panel on Thursday speculating about who should be Time Magazine’s Person of the Year, the debate was about whether the annual milestone cover should feature Karl Rove or God, which seems a false choice since everyone knows they are the same thing. (For Mr. Rove’s sake let’s hope they choose God. As anyone who worked for Henry VIII could tell you, eclipsing your boss is the first step to the Tower.)


The biggest danger to mental health is to sit around debating the rightness or wrongness of Senator Clinton in 2008. Most sane Democrats right now are on a listening tour. Which means listening to each other say they must have a good-ole-boy red-state glad-handing governor, not an intimidating northeastern liberal amazon.


Big donors who never saw a 527 they didn’t like in the 2004 race are now dreading that the Clinton library opening this week will get everyone back on a nostalgia jag again. As one prominent fund-raiser put it, “It will be a great reunion, a time to reminisce. But it doesn’t signify the future. It signifies the past. People forget that when the Clinton war room was created in 1992 we had three TV networks and CNN. There were no blogs or websites. The world has changed and so has politics. We can’t put our hopes in a seance to bring back the spirit of 1992.”


It’s a wan bleat, however, because everyone also knows by the time Ms. Clinton has got done with her transformation back from New York senator to daughter of Chicago crossed with Arkansas they’ll be opening their wallets again with the same old abandon.


You can’t recreate the past, old sport. For real fighting spirit you have to go much further back for inspiration. The Alexander Hamilton exhibit at The New-York Historical society has become the Sunday afternoon rehab center for wounded patriots.


What’s eerie is that the feeling of drift and distraction in New York has an uneasy millennial echo. This is just how it felt on the eve of 9/11 – except that now the drift is overlaid with a deep, unignorable anxiety. All those vengeful phantoms in Fallujah who have fled our conquering armies – are they out there somewhere?


“The objective of securing the safety of Americans from crime and terror has been achieved,” departing Attorney General Ashcroft told us as he headed back to Missouri to play the organ.


But as we read the riveting firsthand reports in that irrelevant, marginal New York Times we dread our new tomorrow.


As author Kati Marton put it fiercely, “Osama Bin Laden knows where the beating heart of America lies – which is why he targeted New York City, not a shopping mall in Kansas.” Memo to Bushies cc Osama: That mighty heart is beating still.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use