At Crossroads of Big Development, Vinegar Hill Perseveres

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

With development in DUMBO encroaching their neighborhood from the west and a busier Brooklyn Navy Yards emerging to their east, residents of Brooklyn’s quaint Vinegar Hill are trying hard to preserve the sleepy atmosphere of their eight-block neighborhood.

“The neighborhood doesn’t look the way it looks because people forgot about it,” a 12-year resident of the neighborhood, Nicholas Evans-Cato, said. “It looks the way it looks because people have fought for it.”

The streets of Vinegar Hill are lined with industrial buildings topped with razor wire. Its treelined side streets are clustered with historic townhouses, some with old storefronts now cloaked in bed sheets.

The hum of the ConEd power plant on the waterfront is one of the only consistent noises. With virtually no shops, Vinegar Hill attracts little foot traffic during the day. One exception: the numerous DUMBO residents who use the cobblestone streets as a parking lot, then traipse back to the other side of the Manhattan Bridge.

The neighborhood is one of the only locations between New York Harbor and Prospect Park to experience little new development, despite its prime position abutting DUMBO and its location just one stop away from Manhattan on the F train.

Even if residents were trying to attract, rather than repel, new development, one obstacle could be the forbidding Farragut Houses, the mammoth public housing complex of 3,440 residents that sits directly across York Street from Vinegar Hill.

Originally known as Irish Town, the neighborhood was home to immigrant workers at the nearby Navy Yards. Its name comes from a 1798 battle of the Irish Rebellion and much of its housing was built in the 1830s and 1850s, in either the Greek Revival or Italianate styles.

Its homes are some of the last remaining brownstones in the area, which saw much of its original housing ripped down to make room for the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway and housing projects like the Farragut Houses during the 1950s..

The neighborhood doesn’t share roadways with the Navy Yards, saving it from much of the traffic other neighborhoods will see during the commercial expansion there.

The city has committed $200 million to upgrading the 300-acre Navy Yards, which were closed in 1966 and reopened five years later as a city-owned industrial park. Now the Navy Yards’ vacancy rate is around 1% for about 4 million square feet of manufacturing space. Another $250 million in private investment in the works would create upwards of one million square feet of new building space, according to the president of the Brooklyn Navy Yard Development Corporation, Andrew Kimball.

Just outside the yards, the development corporation is also planning to raze some historic but rundown mansions on Admiral’s Row to make room for a new retail complex, including a 60,000 square foot supermarket intended to serve the surrounding neighborhood.

But residents who fear encroaching development say their bigger concern is to the west, with the increasing appetite for condos in DUMBO spilling into Vinegar Hill.

Condos began appearing two years ago, and the development at 85 Hudson Avenue was one of the first. Some potential buyers were turned off by the area’s industrial feel, brokers say, but many were sold on the easy access to Manhattan — just one stop away on the F train. Now, a one-bedroom that went for $486,000 in the building two years ago is under contract for $549,000, says Steve Gerber, a broker with the Corcoran Group.

More projects have followed, with mixed results.

After a much-hyped stint on the condo market, The Developers Group took their project at 99 Gold Street rental in April. Now, they’re asking $2,000 a month for 700-square-foot studios and $5,500 for two-bedroom penthouses.

Nearby, the Vista development on Front Street has sold out its 31 units. Prices there ranged from $370,530 for a 537-square-foot studio to $724,914 for a two-bedroom, 1,173 square foot penthouse.

Council Member David Yassky, who represents the neighborhood, said one of the main issues among neighbors is preserving the cobblestone streets, which are often patched with asphalt when city worker come to do repairs. “If you do that enough times, you’ve lost a street,” Mr. Yassky said.

Mr. Yassky also supports the creation of a historic district in neighboring DUMBO, which he says would have a trickle-down effect in Vinegar Hill by discouraging development that does not match the style of the neighborhood.

Townhouses in the neighborhood are harder to come by because there are only about 50 total. Because many have been rented for decades, they’re often found in a state of disrepair and need gut renovations when they do come on the market. Still, there’s tremendous interest from people simply waiting for a home in the area to come on the market.

When Mr. Gerber listed a Vinegar Hill townhouse for $1.295 million last winter he got seven offers — all within the traditionally dead week between Christmas and New Year’s.

Residents say the new development hasn’t changed their area yet – but many of the new condo buyers have yet to move in. When they do, resident Dale Nichols says he hopes they’ll want to keep the industrial feel of the neighborhood, and not change it.

“You have to like that cross between beautiful old homes and the industrial view,” says Mr. Nichols, who bought a wood-frame house in Vinegar Hill two years ago with his girlfriend.

Now, he enjoys looking at the city’s skyline, against the shadows of the waterfront power plant.

“I think it’s just a fantastic thing,” he said. “I was almost upset when they took down some of the stacks.”


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use