The Threshold Issue

On March 13, 2004, Joe Mesi fought Vassiliy Jirov in Las Vegas. Mesi won, but was hit so hard and so often that his brain bled in three places.On May 17, 2004, former heavyweight champion Riddick Bowe, 37, was released from prison after serving 17 months for kidnapping his first wife and their children. At Bowe’s sentencing, his lawyer asked the court for leniency on grounds that Bowe’s judgment had been impaired due to brain damage from boxing.On November 13, 2004, the legendary Evander Holyfield lost 11 of 12 rounds to a journeyman fighter named Larry Donald. Holyfield, 42, has won two of his last nine fights and has just three victories in the past seven years.Most reasonable individuals would conclude that none of these men should box again. But all three are fighting hard outside the ring to prolong their careers inside it.Mesi, 31, and Holyfield are currently under national medical suspension thanks to action taken by state athletic commissions in Nevada and New York. Mesi is appealing his suspension and will travel to Las Vegas for an April 18 hearing before the Nevada state athletic commission’s medical advisory board.Holyfield, who was suspended by the New York commission because of his seriously eroding skill-level, has yet to take direct action in the Empire State. Instead, he has talked about fighting overseas beyond the jurisdiction of U.S. courts.Bowe would not be allowed to fight in Nevada or New York. But due to the chaotic condition of boxing regulation in the U.S., he has been licensed to fight in California and is scheduled to fight Billy Zumbrun tonight. Zumbrun is best known in boxing circles as the fighter who was in the ring with Bradley Rone on July 18, 2003. Rone (who had lost 25 bouts in a row) collapsed after the first round and died.The cases of Mesi, Holyfield, and Bowe raise an issue of broader significance that’s not limited to any one boxer: Should a fighter who is at increased risk of physical injury due to brain damage, diminished physical skills, or other impairment be allowed to fight?Critics of boxing maintain that there’s a certain amount of hypocrisy in refusing to let fighters fight once they’re found to be suffering from a deteriorating physical condition. After all, boxing at its core involves punching people in the head. It accepts the premise that, on occasion, a participant will die within the rules of the sport. Each time a fighter steps into the ring, he’s risking physical injury and death.Conversely, at the libertarian end of the spectrum, one finds boxing maven Charles Jay, who opines, “One of the things that makes me chuckle is the notion that there is always someone out there who knows what’s best for me and knows it better than me. I’ve often marveled at the proposition that there are total strangers who might actually feel more of a proprietary interest in my well-being than I would. Don’t preclude the fighter from making his own choices because you believe you know what’s better for his life than he does.”In other words: It’s my risk, my body, and my life.But the argument in favor of precluding fighters at increased risk from entering the ring is a strong one.First, boxing is regulated. Other sports aren’t. That’s because boxing is legalized assault. It consists of conduct that would be a crime had it not been legalized, but the assault is subject to governmental restrictions. Fights can only take place under rules and regulations that dictate the length of each round, the conduct of fighters in the ring, and hundreds of other guidelines. One of these guidelines is that a boxer must prove his fitness in order to compete. A license to box is a privilege, not a right.Second, one of the underpinnings of a civilized society is that, in certain instances, the state protects people from themselves. That’s why there are laws against certain forms of drug abuse; it’s why passengers are required to wear seatbelts in automobiles and helmets while riding motorcycles. Part of being a boxer is the belief that, if something horrible happens, it will happen to the other guy. But that’s not the way life works. All professional athletes know they won’t be able to compete past a certain point in their lives. And if that point comes sooner rather than later for a fighter, well, that’s life.Third, while the rules and regulations of boxing exist for the protection of fighters, they’re also for the good of the sport. State athletic commissions are guardians of boxing, and letting physically impaired fighters step into the ring is bad for boxing. More than simply hurt the sport’s image, it debases the sport. In sum, it’s the obligation of a state athletic commission to deny a physically impaired fighter a license to fight.Muhammad Ali is a prime example. For years, Ali ennobled boxing. But there came a time when he shouldn’t have been licensed to fight anymore. He was slurring his words like Riddick Bowe does. His skills deteriorated as have Evander Holyfield’s. Ali’s brain, like Joe Mesi’s, had bounced around the inside of his skull too often. The last two fights of Ali’s career (against Larry Holmes and Trevor Berbick) did nothing to enhance his legacy. Now, when people look at Ali, they say, “Boxing did this to him.” The regulators who allowed Ali to fight those last two fights failed in their obligation to him and they betrayed boxing.At various times and in varying ways – in terms of personality, skill, and courage – Joe Mesi, Riddick Bowe, and Evander Holyfield have been likened to Muhammad Ali. It would be a shame if, from a medical standpoint, that comparison turned out to be right.

The Threshold Issue

The Threshold Issue

More from the New York Sun

After Russia’s Reprieve From U.S. Sanctions, Trump Administration Tells Europe To Step Up, Quit Playing Both Sides

Netanyahu Offers High Praise to Trump After U.S. President’s Endorsement, Calling Him Greatest Friend Ever to Israel

Democrats Hold Major Enthusiasm Advantage Headed Into the Midterms, Polls Show

A Sublime Deviation From the Norm

Sonos Gives Its Headphones Another Hearing

Israel Calls on French Jews To Move to the Jewish State as Riots and Arson Engulf France; Macron Addresses Nation

Why So Many American Men Are Afraid of Dressing Well

NATO Eyes Mounting Drone Threat to Romania After Incursions of Airspace, Attacks on Tankers

More from the New York Sun

After Russia’s Reprieve From U.S. Sanctions, Trump Administration Tells Europe To Step Up, Quit Playing Both Sides

Netanyahu Offers High Praise to Trump After U.S. President’s Endorsement, Calling Him Greatest Friend Ever to Israel

Democrats Hold Major Enthusiasm Advantage Headed Into the Midterms, Polls Show

A Sublime Deviation From the Norm

Sonos Gives Its Headphones Another Hearing

Israel Calls on French Jews To Move to the Jewish State as Riots and Arson Engulf France; Macron Addresses Nation

Why So Many American Men Are Afraid of Dressing Well

NATO Eyes Mounting Drone Threat to Romania After Incursions of Airspace, Attacks on Tankers