The Blue Dog Who Barked: Joe Manchin Declares Independence, Completing the Extinction of the Species Known as Blue Dog Democrats

Senator Manchin, the two-term Democrat of West Virginia, is declaring himself an independent. The last moderate voice for his party in the upper house of Congress, his declaration completes Capitol Hill’s devolution into left-and-right factions that undermine chances of consensus and compromise.Mr. Manchin, in his statement yesterday, said that since entering public service in 1982, he has “always focused on doing what’s best for my state and my country, without regard to party or politics.” He expressed pride in a “commitment to common sense, bipartisanship” and a “desire to bring people together.”“I have never seen America through a partisan lens,” Mr. Manchin insisted, but he lamented observing a shift since entering the Senate in 2010. He described Republicans and Democrats as drifting to “partisan extremism while jeopardizing our democracy.”“Today,” Mr. Manchin said, “our national politics are broken, and neither party is willing to compromise to find common ground. To stay true to myself and remain committed to put country before party, I have decided to register as an independent with no party affiliation and continue to fight for America’s sensible majority.”Mr. Manchin will still caucus with Democrats. So his declaration won’t change the balance of power in the Senate, leaving his former party with a one-vote majority. For his loyalty, he’ll remain chairman of the Energy and Natural Resources Committee.Along with another Democrat-turned-independent, Senator Sinema of Arizona, Mr. Manchin had bucked his party’s attempts to end the filibuster. With both gone next year, should Democrats maintain control of the chamber, a safeguard of rights for the minority — one that forced compromise — would be without defenders.The Founders designed the Senate to be less vulnerable to passing political passions. Senators serve six years, long enough for heated debates of the present to cool. Members of the House, though, are elected every two years and so are more reflective of the zeitgeist, and it was there that the nation’s drift into partisanship began to appear.In February of last year, I wrote in these columns about the House Blue Dog Coalition of moderate-to-conservative Democrats. It was formed in 1995. At its peak in 2007, it represented 20 percent of the Democratic caucus. After the 2022 elections, it had shrunk to just seven members or three percent.“Partisanship,” I wrote, “has rendered compromise and consensus things of the past on Capitol Hill. A few Blue Dogs will still roam the halls of Congress for the next few years seeking pats on the head from the GOP, but with their diminished numbers, the Democratic Party’s ascendent left needs no longer fear their bite.”Now, Mr. Manchin’s growling about his party’s left-wing impulses on issues from spending and regulations to the filibuster and foreign policy has fallen silent, too. He will finish out his term in January when it’s a near certainty that West Virginia will choose a Republican to replace him.Thursday on X, Governor Justice of West Virginia, the Republican nominee for Mr. Manchin’s seat, wrote that the “guilty verdict against President Trump is a deeply troubling and politicized decision that undermines the principles of justice,” signaling how he’ll vote in the Senate.If Mr. Justice wins and becomes another staunch voice for his party’s prevailing positions, he would have plenty of company on both sides of the aisle. The press wouldn’t seek him out as it does Mr. Manchin, and the public would know where he stands on a given issue without asking.The result of the partisan realignment in Congress has been fewer congressional seats in play. In 2022, the reelection rate for House incumbents was 94.5 percent. In the Senate, it was a clean sweep. These victories were helped by hard stances that inspire voters in ways promises of moderation and compromise don’t.Mr. Manchin will still be a voice to harry the conscience of his former party. Yet his departure will leave a more partisan Capitol Hill, where no Blue Dogs bark, and President Hayes’ advice, “He serves his party best who serves his country best,” is seen as a quaint relic of better days in government.

The Blue Dog Who Barked: Joe Manchin Declares Independence, Completing the Extinction of the Species Known as Blue Dog Democrats

The Blue Dog Who Barked: Joe Manchin Declares Independence, Completing the Extinction of the Species Known as Blue Dog Democrats

More from the New York Sun

Against Tight Deadline, Appeals Court Considers Reinstating Missouri Republicans’ Redistricting

Ethan Hawke Bears ‘The Weight’ of the Depression

The Land of the Free Gets a Selective Therapy Session

The Unlikely Afterlife of ‘Come On Eileen’

Sotomayor v. Plain Language

The Day After the Fed Rate Hike, Financial Markets Applaud Kevin Warsh, Who Keeps Trump’s Confidence

Could Trump Bring a Surprise Guest to His Parley at the UN?

El-Sayed Tries To Sidestep Furor Over Hasan Piker’s Al Qaeda Comments — Says He’s More Concerned About Trump’s ‘Dangerous Policies’

More from the New York Sun

Against Tight Deadline, Appeals Court Considers Reinstating Missouri Republicans’ Redistricting

Ethan Hawke Bears ‘The Weight’ of the Depression

The Land of the Free Gets a Selective Therapy Session

The Unlikely Afterlife of ‘Come On Eileen’

Sotomayor v. Plain Language

The Day After the Fed Rate Hike, Financial Markets Applaud Kevin Warsh, Who Keeps Trump’s Confidence

Could Trump Bring a Surprise Guest to His Parley at the UN?

El-Sayed Tries To Sidestep Furor Over Hasan Piker’s Al Qaeda Comments — Says He’s More Concerned About Trump’s ‘Dangerous Policies’